Tuesday 26 September 2023
Select a region

African staff "afraid" to voice workplace concerns in Jersey

African staff

Thursday 01 June 2023

African staff "afraid" to voice workplace concerns in Jersey

Thursday 01 June 2023

Some work permit holders from Africa feel "afraid" to seek help or share grievances with their employers over concerns they might lose their job, which is often tied to accommodation, a Scrutiny panel has heard.

Friends of Africa CI told the Work Permit Holder Welfare Review panel – a group of politicians who are currently scrutinising the effectiveness of the island's work permit policy – that workers often refrain from speaking out on workplace concerns.

Chair of the panel Deputy Beatriz Porée described the feedback as "sobering information", but added that it was "important" for the review of work permit holders' welfare.


Pictured: Panel chair Beatriz Porée described the feedback as "sobering information".

Washington Gwatidzo, Chair of Friends of Africa CI, said that the charity was set up to "champion diversity and inclusion" in Jersey and to celebrate different cultures in the island.

Mr Gwatidzo said: "Putting your head above the parapet and reporting your employer is a scary thing to do."

Another member of Friends of Africa CI, Lesley Katsande, said that there was a feeling among African workers that challenging an employer and "put[ting] their head above the parapet" may impact their ability to return to the island.

"Migrant workers are not empowered to stand up for themselves," Ms Katsande added. "Employers are not answerable to anyone, unless it's the Tax Department or Social Security.

"But regardless of where you are from, discrimination is difficult to tackle."

Arthur Kembo, who previously worked as a work permit holder in Jersey, also shared concerns with the panel.


Pictured: The Friends of Africa CI charity promotes, shares, celebrates and enhances the profile of African culture and Africa in Jersey.

"Work permit holders are tied to their employer for one year – they can't leave their employment. If they do leave their employer, then they have to leave the island – as an employee, you have no rights," he said.

In a separate hearing, the Kenyan Jersey Committee shared also shared their views. The panel heard that there are approximately 1,000 Kenyans living in Jersey.

Committee Secretary Joshua Mushuri said that the biggest grievance for Kenyan work permit holders is that they can only work for one employer.

"The work permit holders come here to make income – in their free time, they are not allowed to make more of an income," he said.


Are Jersey's work permit holders safe from modern slavery?

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Aston Francis on
It is a wider phenomenon, part of the so called Jersey Way. Putting your head above the parapet and reporting your employer is a scary thing to do also for white employees. There are many examples of people working for Health department being bullied or losing their jobs after they submitted complaints concerning their managers. The complaints get discouraged and derailed. People are genuinely scared. BE reported on an anonymous letter from early October claiming widespread bullying in the hospital. Susanne Wylie promised prompt investigation. Now 8 months later they hope public to forget or get distracted with the latest scary news from Health, Education and possibly other departments. So at least it doesn’t seem to be selectively discriminating the African staff.
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?