Monday 02 October 2023
Select a region

Bananas and Yarnham: The hospital debate's most bizarre moments

Bananas and Yarnham: The hospital debate's most bizarre moments

Friday 08 October 2021

Bananas and Yarnham: The hospital debate's most bizarre moments

Friday 08 October 2021

It might have been perhaps the most important States Assembly debate of a generation – but it certainly wasn’t without its more bizarre moments.

This week, States Members gathered to debate whether the Government should be able to borrow £800m to build a new hospital at Overdale.

Having escaped a bid to cap spending at £550m by two votes, the Government's £800m borrowing plan was approved 32-14.

Throughout, there was talk of debt markets, productivity and inflation – all the thinking one might (and should) expect to find surrounding a decision that may hit  

But there was also, as has become a tradition of the States Assembly for better or worse (worse), a hearty helping of odd occurrences.

Oh well (oh well) 

While States Members have been sitting virtually for more than a year now, the trials and tribulations of Microsoft Teams were still apparent…

Senator Sarah Ferguson: Somebody’s got their microphone on. Will they please turn it off?

Reverb: (Off)

Bailiff: I’m sorry Senator, we can’t hear anything other than you speaking. 

Senator Ferguson: I can hear somebody spluttering in the background. Oh well.

Reverb: (Oh well)

Senator Ferguson: There it is again!  

Diving footballers

Assistant Treasury Minister Deputy Lindsay Ash: “If Manchester City football club took to the field wearing deep-sea divers’ boots, they would not win the Premier League, they wouldn’t even win against the Jersey Bulls.”

He’s not wrong.

An offer you can refuse 

So keen to get the plan through, Home Affairs Minister and leader of the Jersey Alliance Party Deputy Gregory Guida offered Reform Jersey a "trade".

He said that if the party voted against the £550m cap amendment and in favour of the Government’s borrowing plan, he would not stand in the next election.

He said that this would mean they would have not only defeated their “fiercest enemy” but the leader of the “largest party in Jersey”.

Deputy Guida will be standing for election next year, it can be confirmed.

Deputy Montfort…Python?

Deputy Monty Tadier attempted to “dismantle” the Government’s argument that capping the cost of the project at £550m would effectively cancel the idea of a new hospital – something many referred to as “gun to the head” tactics – with the help of Monty Python.

Pictured: Senator Sam Mezec tweets his support of his Reform Party colleague.

“What I would say is that first of all when dealing with an assailant with a weapon, you have to disarm the assailant. Luckily, what we have with the Council of Ministers isn’t a gun to the head, it’s actually just a banana in a sock, which they’re pointing at us.

“When you take the sock off, you realise that the Council of Ministers are just standing there with a banana and they can do no harm… You get the banana off them, and you peel the banana and then you eat the banana thus disarming him.

He continued: “What we realise here is that we don’t have a gun to the head at all, we have a banana, and that the banana can do us no harm because in fact the gun to the head is saying there will be delay… but of course that’s not true. There won’t be delays over this.”

Total stitch-up

In an unusual turn of events, leader of the hospital project Senator Lyndon Yarn-ham started his speech by telling the Assembly that he had learnt over lunchtime that Reform Jersey’s Deputy Rob Ward’s family had introduced him to crochet because it keeps him quiet... before producing a red yarn and gifting it to him. 


Picture: Senator Lyndon Farnham stitches up Deputy Rob Ward. 

The gift generated much laughter in the Assembly, which was reignited when Deputy Ward thanked him, but noted a “fundamental error”.

“The crochet needle he bought is far too big for the wool,” he pointed out, saying he would stop short of making a tongue-in-cheek joke about having had the problem before.

Just do it! 

Senator Kristina Moore returned to the crochet theme as she made her closing speech in favour of capping the hospital cost.

“The gift itself of a crochet kit reminded me of the people during the French Revolution watching the aristocracy at the guillotine as they sat in the square knitting.”


Pictured: Senator Moore laced her closing speech with a few jabs at Senator Yarn-ham.

She added that she had her own gift for Senator Farnham “because I know he likes running” – a pair of shoelaces.

“They say, ‘Just build it!’ But I have added my own comment, ‘not at any cost’.”

His Excellency 

Halfway through yesterday afternoon’s debate, Greffier Mark Egan made the shock announcement between speeches: 

“I’m delighted to say we’ve been joined in the gallery by His Excellency, Mr Mansoor Abulhoul, the Ambassador of the United Arab Emirates, and we welcome him to the island, and to our Chamber. 

“I hope you have an excellent stay, Sir.” 

Good that everyone was on their best behaviour, then.


£800m hospital borrowing plan given green light

Bid to cap hospital spend at £550m fails

BLOW-BY-BLOW: How the £800m hospital funding debate unfolded

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?