Tuesday 03 October 2023
Select a region

Luxury Bouley Bay home inquiry officially off the table

Luxury Bouley Bay home inquiry officially off the table

Friday 23 September 2022

Luxury Bouley Bay home inquiry officially off the table

Friday 23 September 2022

The Environment Minister has confirmed that there will be no public inquiry into the luxury home development planned for the former Water’s Edge Hotel at Bouley Bay.

It comes after the Royal Court ruled last month that Deputy Jonathan Renouf's predecessor, Deputy John Young, had acted unlawfully by launching an inquiry without adequate justification.

Plans to convert the Water's Edge into a home with guest accommodation, a pool, tennis courts and extensive landscaped gardens were first put forward in June last year, attracting nearly 200 public comments.

Challenging the proposed planning inquiry in a judicial review, applicants WE Jersey argued before the Royal Court that that a series of emails – including one where he describes his decision as “not negotiable” – were proof former Deputy John Young had shown bias against the Bouley Bay application.


Pictured: Former Environment Minister Deputy John Young.

They also argued that the reasons given by the Minister for launching into a planning inquiry – the island's housing needs and the Coastal National Park – were inadequate.

While Commissioner Julian Clyde-Smith disagreed that there was "pre-determination" on the Minister's part, he agreed that his references to the Coastal National Park and the island's housing needs were not sufficient to justify a planning inquiry and subsequently ruled it "unlawful".

Jonathan Renouf.jpg

Pictured: New Environment Minister, Deputy Jonathan Renouf.

Whether or not to attempt to call another inquiry was then left in the hands of the new Minister.

However, today, Deputy Renouf has confirmed that he wishes for the Water's Edge application to be dealt with via the usual planning process - due to the number of comments on the application, this will be via the Planning Committee.

Trinity Constable Philip Le Sueur chairs the committee, which consists of: Deputies Steve Luce, Mary Le Hegarat, Andy Howell, Tom Coles and Alex Curtis, and Constables Kevin Lewis, Richard Honeycombe, Deidre Mezbourian and Marcus Troy.

"Following careful consideration of the Royal Court's decision, I have decided not to intervene in this planning application. In arriving at this decision, I am not expressing any view on the merits of the plans," Deputy Renouf said.


IN-DEPTH: Court rules Bouley Bay luxury home inquiry “unlawful”

"Gaping hole" in Water’s Edge inquiry decision, court hears

Water's Edge applicant wins first round in fight to stop planning inquiry

Legal fight to block inquiry into Bouley Bay luxury home plan

Agreement reached on future of Bouley Bay Dive Centre

Future of Bouley Bay diving business 'uncertain'

Plans to convert former Bouley Bay hotel into single landscaped home

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Scott Mills on
What a shame, what will the "experts from UK" do now? as a lot have become reliant on Jersey's spending with such previous inquiries/reports etc...
Posted by on
Another common sense decision by the new council of ministers.

Thank goodness they have been elected to power.

The island has some hope now.
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?