Wednesday 18 May 2022
Select a region

Parish concerns over hospital plans dash hopes of fresh Gov deal

Parish concerns over hospital plans dash hopes of fresh Gov deal

Friday 07 January 2022

Parish concerns over hospital plans dash hopes of fresh Gov deal

Friday 07 January 2022

St. Helier is unlikely to reach a fresh deal with the Government over land it owns around Overdale because it still has “serious concerns” about plans for a new hospital, which it says it will present at the forthcoming planning inquiry.

Constable Simon Crowcroft said that the recent decision of parishioners to reject a £6.5m offer from Government for land around the People’s Park had been overwhelming and unequivocal.

This meant it was highly unlikely, he said, that St. Helier would reach a settlement with the Government, even though ministers had said that a deal could still be struck as it formally started the process to acquire the land by compulsory purchase.

This was decided by a recent ministerial decision, taken by Assistant Environment Minister Gregory Guida.

Land the Government wants to acquire includes the parking along Peirson Road, the Inn of the Park car park, all 69 car parking spaces along the People’s Park, the Jersey Bowling Club site and verges alongside Westmount Road.

Pictured: St. Helier object to plans to change the junction between Westmount Road and Tower Road.

It also plans to forcibly buy the driveway, a strip of land and raiser planter at the entrance to a property in Westmount Road.

The report accompanying the decision states: “For the avoidance of doubt, it is acknowledged that agreement can be reached during the process of compulsory purchase.”

However, Mr Crowcroft said he was grateful to his parishioners for rejecting the Government’s offer last month.

“I now feel I am in a much stronger position, both as a Roads Committee member and Constable, to present a clear case to the planning inquiry,” he said. 

“We are not against the building of a hospital at Overdale, but have serious concerns about the way it has been designed and presented, in particular, the so-called UK-style super-highway up Westmount Road and also proposed junction changes with Tower Road.

“It is going to affect thousands of people and will gridlock large parts of the ring road.”

He added: “When States Members agreed the access plans, I don’t think everyone appreciated how much of a car-based hospital this is, and what its impact on the island’s capital would be.

“One of the reasons St. Saviour’s Hospital was rejected as a site was that it would require too many car journeys, but Overdale is equally bowing down to the motor car.

“For instance, few people may realise that the ‘active travel corridor’ only goes up the hill so cyclists coming down will have to merge with traffic.”


Pictured: St Helier argue that not having a dedicated cycle lane going down Westmount Road is dangerous.

The Constable said that the Government could not complete the compulsory purchase process until planning permission is granted.

“The project team designed a hospital around car use and have only proposed half-baked arrangements when it comes to sustainable transport,” he said. “Instead, they are saying they will monitor things afterwards. We are missing in a once-in-a-generation opportunity.

“It has also been enormously stressful for the Jersey Bowling Club, an ancient and well-established institution. Planning permission is yet to be granted for Warwick Farm and the move is still up in the air. The club would much prefer to stay where they are. 

“Also, in the week we mark the Battle of Jersey, it is a timely reminder that the Westmount Road highway will destroy Peirson’s Bluff, where the militia grouped before repelling the French invasion. An important piece of Jersey history will be gone forever.”

St. Helier's Roads Committee is currently preparing its comments on the hospital planning application, which will be finalised at a meeting next week.

Express delved into their concerns in depth here.


Gov makes £6.5m bid for St. Helier land

INSIGHT: The full details of the £6.5m St. Helier hospital deal

100 parking spaces to be removed under St. Helier hospital deal

St. Helier rejects £6.5m land deal

Gov ready to force land sale for new hospital highway

Jersey Hemp's lease to be changed ahead of Bowling Club move

FOCUS: Parish officials pick holes in hospital highway plans


Express spoke to one of the individuals in charge of the parish's finances about what the £6.5m deal would have meant for St. Helier, and how the compulsory purchase process would look...

St. Helier's £6.5m question

PODCAST - St. Helier's £6.5m question

Subscribe to Bailiwick Podcasts on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Deezer or Whooshkaa.

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Paul Troalic on
What a great shame that the management of the Bowling Club haven't publicly stated their views regarding their forced removal to Warwick Farm. This could hav3 added a lot of weight to our argument to reject both Overdale and Westmount arose changes.
The environmental issues regarding car use also appear to have been forgotten by the Our Hospital Team.
In my view all credibility for this project was lost a long time ago.
Posted by Keith Marsh on
The points raised and requests for the future by St. Helier's Roads Committee sound reasonable and would certainly get more of the Parish vote. Over to you C.M. "crack the whip".
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?