Sunday 26 June 2022
Select a region

COMMENT: Is life in Jersey getting better or worse?

COMMENT: Is life in Jersey getting better or worse?

Monday 24 February 2020

COMMENT: Is life in Jersey getting better or worse?

Monday 24 February 2020

Statistics Jersey have just published an updated Better Life Index.

I think it's a really great initiative to have a broader based measure of how Jersey is doing, especially one that is comparable with elsewhere.

So, well done Statistics Jersey. Overall, we ended up just above average, but behind the UK and France. The highest score for those countries making up the index was for Norway, and the lowest South Africa. You can read the full index here. 

As well as the opportunity to compare with other participants on an overall basis, we can also see how we rank for the various dimensions that make up the index. For example whilst we are above average for jobs and earnings, we are well below the average for net disposable income, in spite of our higher earnings and low tax rates.  Work / life balance also scores badly, reflecting just how hard people in Jersey have to work to get by, and it seems to be getting worse.

Under the housing dimension, an area which I have said in previous columns I am sure is at the root of many other problems, the good news was nearly every household has a flushing toilet, but sadly & very surprisingly, not quite all of them. Our spending on housing at 26% of net adjusted disposable income puts us bottom of that dimension.


Pictured: "Our spending on housing at 26% of net adjusted disposable income puts us bottom of that dimension."

Subjective, but arguably most important of all, is the overall score for life satisfaction. Here, we were ranked just about average, a long drop from when the report was first published in 2013, which rated us 3rd just below Norway & Denmark, countries that still lead the pack. So on this measure the trend is worrying. Just what is the cause and what should we do?

Our worst performance was on civic engagement. Very sadly many of us seem to have given up on voting and politicians to improve our lives. Disturbing, when you think that it is only 75 years since Jersey experienced life without democracy.

I must admit I have been surprised, disappointed and concerned by the latest index. I happen to think Jersey is a fantastic place, but I am one of the lucky ones. Born at a time when it was easier to get a job, houses were cheaper and tax rates even lower than they are now. Some of my generation even benefit from final salary based pensions that increase with inflation.  Looking around at issues like housing and the pressure on people I can begin to understand why my privileged view of the world is no longer the average view.

Hopefully our political leaders will be thinking very carefully about our latest performance on the Better Life Index. I would like to believe that they are now really worried, and the Chief Minister will be thumping the table and tasking Ministers and officers to work out what they (and we) should be doing to turn things around, and quickly.

READ MORE from Kevin...

Look at the bigger picture

It's time to re-consider the bridge to France

A little less consultation and a little more action please!

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by John Henwood on
Kevin Keen continues to show the sort of leadership, experience and plain old common sense that is sadly absent in so many of our elected members. A dozen Kevin Keens in the States would certainly make a huge difference, but instead we have an Assembly with inexperienced, straight-out-of-education members, left of centre axe-grinders and ineffective publicity seekers whose main aim seems to be getting re-elected. Of course, there are some strong and able individuals, but far too few in number. No surprise that we are so low in the league table for civic engagement.
Posted by Bob Wareing-Jones on
Like John Henwood, I too would like to see half a dozen Kevin Keens in the States, actually just 1 might be enough to shake them all up a bit and begin to see common sense. Sadly I fear, unless we change radically the way we govern and how we govern, voter turnout will continue to be very poor. Learning to govern from the bottom up rather than top down would be a good start. In other words, governing for the common good.
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?