Jersey Finance calls for "rational debate" around finance centres

Friday 08 June 2018

Jersey Finance has welcomed the publication of a new paper which seeks to dispel the myths surrounding international financial centres (IFCs) and calls for a more “rational debate” around the essential function of IFCs in facilitating global trade and investment.

“The Benefits of Capital Mobility," published by the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA), with support from Jersey Finance, examines the growing importance of IFCs in the global economy and argues they are in reality benchmarks for transparency and good governance.

It argues that clamping down on IFCs would not raise tax revenues for larger countries and preserve existing levels of investment but would rather change investment flows by politicising investment decisions. The paper also illustrates how the tax neutrality offered by IFCs benefits investors and countries in terms of investment in infrastructure, wealth creation and future prosperity. 

Amongst the key conclusions drawn in the paper are:  

• the success of IFCs lies in three key drivers: an increase in the global stock of investable capital; the rise of new investment opportunities outside Western Europe and North America; and the growth of tax and regulatory intervention by governments
• as more investment capital is allocated across a diverse range of jurisdictions from investors around the world, IFCs help mitigate the potential for multiple taxation, ultimately having a positive impact on investment returns which compounds over time
• undermining the existence of IFCs would harm investment, economic growth and international capital flows, while the promised benefits from intervention are unlikely to materialise

Pictured: The paper concluded that clamping down on IFC's would change investment flows by politicising investment decisions.

Geoff Cook, CEO of Jersey Finance, commented: “When it comes to cross-border financial services, there is still a considerable amount of misunderstanding and misrepresentation. We think it is vital to form judgments based on facts. For this reason we are committed to providing a clearer picture of the reality through research, with the aim of prompting a sensible, more focused conversation on what it is that centres like Jersey actually do.

“This paper helps in that regard, seeking to reframe the international financial services debate and clarifying, with facts, the positive impact Jersey can have on the futures of people all over the world.”

Commenting on the report, Jamie Whyte, Director of Research at the IEA, said: “Offshore banking centres play an important role in the global economy, increasing international investment and economic growth. The attacks on them by European politicians are little more than demagoguery and a desire to eliminate tax competition.”

Mr Cook added: “As far as Jersey is concerned, its core proposition is its ability to provide a transparent, simple and cost-effective platform for international investors, including sovereign wealth funds, governments, institutions and private investors. 

“By doing so, we are providing a valuable function, enabling, for instance, infrastructure development in developed and developing countries, generating better returns on the pension funds of more than 60 million people around the world, and helping to create job opportunities for hundreds of thousands of people. We think it’s a role worth defending, and I’ve been pleased to work with the IEA to help illustrate this fact.”