Sunday 01 October 2023
Select a region

Carbon neutrality “going too fast”? Too slow, says Jersey Electricity

Carbon neutrality “going too fast”? Too slow, says Jersey Electricity

Tuesday 22 February 2022

Carbon neutrality “going too fast”? Too slow, says Jersey Electricity

Tuesday 22 February 2022

While the Infrastructure Minister has argued that green transport plans are progressing "too fast", Jersey Electricity thinks that the island can "do more and faster" to progress towards carbon neutrality.

Grilled by politicians tasked with assessing his department's Carbon Neutral Roadmap last week, Deputy Kevin Lewis said he did not think Jersey was "anywhere near ready" when it came to electrification of transport as a way of achieving the island's net-zero emissions goal.

The ambition had previously been to reach net neutrality by 2030, but the Roadmap revises this target to 2050.

However, in a written submission to the Environment, Housing and Infrastructure Panel for their Carbon Neutral Roadmap Review, Jersey Electricity took a very different view of the pace of change.

Writing on behalf of the company, Director of Commercial Services Peter Cadiou states that although JEC understands the Government's "decision not to commit to carbon neutrality by 2030”, it supports an “even earlier target than 2050”.

"Net-zero by 2050 is simply in line with most other countries and these countries are, in any case, unlikely to want to do business with Jersey, in any meaningful way, without seeing that minimum level of commitment," Mr Cadiou said.

He further noted that electricity in Jersey is “already virtually completely decarbonised” due to a large amount of low-carbon nuclear and hydro power being imported from the European grid.

Heating, cooking and road transport, which together make up “70% of Jersey’s total carbon emissions”, are targeted as areas where low-carbon electric solutions can be facilitated.


Pictured: Heating, cooking and road transport contribute to 70% of CO2 emissions in Jersey.

"Many of these technologies when coupled with energy efficiency are readily available today – with Jersey’s challenge largely being one of incentivisation (and dis-incentivisation) and delivery," he continued.

"We are therefore supportive of the policy proposals that encourage this, for example, EV subsidies, grant support for EV charging infrastructure, vehicle scrappage support, an end to petrol and diesel vehicle imports and installation of new fossil fuel boilers, home energy certificates, grants to aid energy conservation and fuel switches."

Elsewhere in the submission, he explains that JEC supports the creation of an Energy Minister, as well as a 'Decarbonisation Unit' and 'Carbon Neutral Alliance'.

Jonathan Best, Director of fuel company ATF, also made a submission to the panel.

“We support the overall aims of the carbon neutral roadmap,” he wrote, but added that ATF was “disappointed” that its proposal to introduce a minimum level of renewable fuels sold in Jersey was not included in the Carbon Neutral Roadmap.

Mr Best says ATF wants to see distributors required to sell fuels with a 'bio' element of 10% ethanol in petrol or 7% fatty acid methyl esters (known as FAME) in diesel.

The resulting fuels are called E10 and B7, respectively.

“The main benefit of these fuels is that they reduce overall levels of CO2 emissions. By blending the fuel, less fossil fuel is required, helping protect the environment and meeting climate change targets," Mr Best explains.


Pictured: ATF campaigned to bring mandated minimum sales of E10 and B7 fuels to Jersey, which are lower in carbon than their non-diluted counterparts.

A quote from the UK government is included in his letter: “The introduction of E10 petrol at UK forecourts could cut transport CO2 emissions by 750,000 tonnes a year - the equivalent of taking 350,000 cars off the road.” 

“When applied to Jersey, we believe this would equate to 6,841 cars," Mr Best added.


Express recently spoke to Steve Skelton, the Government's Group Director, Strategy and Innovation, about the Carbon Neutral Roadmap for the Bailiwick Podcast...

The road to carbon neutrality

POD carbon neutral thumbnail.jpg

Subscribe to Bailiwick Podcasts on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Deezer or Whooshkaa.


Green transport plans "going too fast", says Minister in charge

“Banning new hybrid cars will add more carbon, not remove it”

Wanted: Extra £250m to achieve 2030 carbon neutral goal

Jersey way off carbon reduction target set seven years ago

Government aims to push back carbon target to 2050

FOCUS: Which Climate Assembly recommendations is Gov backing?

New strategy "dereliction of duty", says climate emergency politician

Electric car and heating subsidies on road to carbon neutrality

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Frustrated Islander on
The only electricity provider in Jersey is asking us to speed up the carbon neutral goals rather than slow down. The best way to do this to use the low/no carbon electricity they sell, a company which is majority owned by the States.

Before we enter further into a monopoly arrangement where we rely almost entirely on the electricity sold by one company, how about we adopt the same approach as we did with Jersey Telecoms and open the market up to competition? I am slightly nervous that we are looking to put almost everything with one firm, who can charge what they want.
Posted by on
This is absolutely absurd.

Where are the financial implications for the paying public of running an electric vehicle compared to petrol or diesel? People can not afford to buy vehicles that are not fit for their purpose and do not meet the basic requirements of commuters.

They are far too expensive and are unaffordable for the majority of people.

The real issue is that after decades of developing a product that nobody wants to buy, the manufacturers in conjunction with the world governments are forcing us to pay for a product that is not fit for purpose and too expensive to run.
Posted by Sarah Ferguson on
The island grid is not capable of dealing with the demand if we all have electric cars for a start. And then there is the fact that the net zero is based on the results of computer modeling and, if we dont know the assumptions, how reliable are the models. Note - Professor Ferguson’s (no relation) models of the covid epidemic which were garbage. The genuine scientific evidence - which the scientifically illiterate majority of the population has ignored - is that the death and destruction forecasts are wishful thinking by zealots hoping to frighten us into submission. We are nothing like as warm as the Minoan or the Early Roman warm periods for a start. More carbon dioxide encourages plant growth (increased photosynthesis and bumper crops), doesn’t warm the climate.
Please can people take the trouble to do some research and not rely on fake news.
Posted by Simon Langlois on
Blue lights flashing and sirens on, a fire engine is hurtling down the road to save the lives of people in a burning building. Someone sees them in their mirror and feels they're going too fast. They decide to deliberately slow them down! What do we think of that person and what is the likely outcome?

Let's just hope that the forthcoming elections will clear the road ahead of people like that.

As for the driver who tells everyone that there is no fire and the increasing temperatures are a good thing (!!!!!), thank goodness they've decided to pull over to the side of the road on 22nd June.
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?