Select a region
Both the Chief Minister and Treasury Minister have said that they support the "principle" of buying a former café at Grève de Lecq to safeguard it for the public.
However, Deputies Kristina Moore and Ian Gorst, who represent voters in the north-west of the island, argue that a debate in the States Assembly isn't the best way to achieve that.
They argue that the proposal to acquire the land – originally put forward by Deputy Lyndon Farnham, who also represents the district – should be deferred while negotiations with the owner take place.
They shared their position after the fourth Deputy in the district, Lucy Stephenson, proposed a change to Deputy Farnham's proposal, seeking to, among other things, find a way to make it easier for the States to purchase similar sites to the former Seaside Café and its large car park.
Deputy Moore said: "Deputy Gorst and I are aligned with Deputy Stephenson, who has been dealing with this issue since last year's election, along with Infrastructure Minister Tom Binet. We support the principle [of purchase] but do not consider that a debate in the Assembly would be in the best interests of the public.
"We would prefer if Deputy Farnham’s proposition was deferred at this stage to allow for more formal talks with the owner in order to negotiate the best price."
Deputy Farnham proposal, which will be debated at the next States sitting, asks for approval to buy the coastal site, which is on the market for £5m undeveloped or £11m with a four-bedroomed luxury home and 100-cover café, which have planning permission.
Pictured: The café and car park is currently fenced off and unable to be used by the public.
Deputy Stephenson's amendment seeks to guarantee that the site, if purchased, will be of ‘environmental, cultural and social benefit’ to the public, which could involve partner organisations, such as the Bosdet Foundation, coming on board.
The Assistant Chief Minister also wants to find a better way for the Government to become aware of properties or land which it might want to buy on behalf of the public.
Her amendment asks the Treasury Minister to “consider options, consulting as necessary, for enabling the Government to be notified when properties or areas of significant value to the people of Jersey become available so that early consideration can be given to potentially acquiring them on behalf of the public.”
Pictured: Deputy Farnham described the site as appearing to be "in limbo".
Explaining the rationale behind this particular proposal, Deputy Stephenson said: “The Café Romany site does not represent the first occasion on which the States has found itself on the back foot in respect of potentially acquiring properties or areas of land that are of value to Islanders.
“On occasions, we have managed to make up lost ground, but on other occasions the opportunity has passed us by entirely, and we now look on with regret at subsequent developments or loss of public amenity.
“I appreciate this is a delicate subject, and the part [of the amendment] has therefore been drafted carefully and broadly, but I believe it is worth considering how we can avoid similar scenarios in future.”
The States has supported the purchase of private land for public benefit before. In 2014, the Assembly approved giving the National Trust a £3.57m contribution towards its £7.15m purchase of the former Pontins Holiday Village at Plémont.
Push to buy "iconic" Grève de Lecq to safeguard public access
Green light for Grève de Lecq pool and underground gym
Comments
Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.