Tuesday 18 January 2022
Select a region

Chief Minister “can’t recall” discussing plan to cap hospital borrowing

Chief Minister “can’t recall” discussing plan to cap hospital borrowing

Thursday 11 November 2021

Chief Minister “can’t recall” discussing plan to cap hospital borrowing

The Chief Minister has said he doesn't remember whether Ministers considered a backbench push to bring down borrowing on the new hospital by £250m before the crucial funding plan was agreed.

Senator John Le Fondré made the comment as he was grilled by politicians over the funding proposals in the Government Plan yesterday.

Arguing that the proposed 'Our Hospital' budget of £804m budget was too high and not evidence-based, the Future Hospital Review Panel put forward a plan to cap the overall budget at £550m and the level of borrowing at £400m earlier this year.

In a report referencing a survey by Express in which 80% of respondents said they did not want the Government to borrow £800m through two bonds worth £400m eachthe panel instead suggested that Treasury looked at alternative funding sources like “the windfall payment of approximately £40m resulting from JT’s sale of its IoT business.” 

But their plan was narrowly defeated in a States Assembly vote, and the Government’s original borrowing plans were then approved after a lengthy debate.

Appearing before the Government Plan Review Panel yesterday, Senator Le Fondré said he “honestly couldn’t recall” whether the Council of Ministers had considered the amendment. 


Pictured: Senator Kristina Moore said it was "extraordinary" that the Chief Minister couldn't remember whether Ministers had even considered the idea of capping borrowing as her panel had suggested.

He said that he had “moved on” from the topic and suggested that was why he couldn’t remember such discussions, arguing that he had since been busy dealing with “Brexit and fishing."

The Panel’s Chair, Senator Kristina Moore, said it was “quite extraordinary” he didn’t recollect discussing an amendment that could have saved such a significant sum of money, but the Chief Minister disagreed.

Express contacted the Government to verify whether Ministers did discuss the proposals.

A spokesperson responded late last night: "The Council of Ministers discussed Scrutiny’s amendment to the hospital budget in late September and early October.

"During these discussions, Ministers considered different ways to approach the budget, but ultimately they strongly opposed the proposed amendment as damaging to the delivery of a much needed new hospital and maintained their proposed budget as the best value for Jersey. This was agreed by the Assembly."

A planning application for the new hospital is due to be submitted by Monday 15 November.


BLOW-BY-BLOW: The £800m hospital funding debate (live updates) 

Push to cap future hospital spend at £550m

Government planning to borrow full £800m for new hospital 

Survey signals opposition to £800m hospital borrowing plan

FOCUS: The Big Borrow - going £1.8bn into debt and paying it off

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by MichaelEvans46 on
He can’t remember a discussion involving hundreds of millions of pounds! The bloke is a joke and a disgrace, should never be elected again for anything
Posted by Scott Mills on
yeah I often conveniently forget everything when I asked. I call it the "Fondre Force" Lovely beaches out there.
Posted by Martin on
Whilst decisions of a quarter of a BILLION pounds may be often for our Chief Minister I would have thought that SUCH a sum was worthy of Official Gov minutes which should have been perused & signed off by Le EFF or changed accordingly!

REALLY THOUGH it is NOTHING to worry about - JUST £250 million of public money!

I can remember the 1st time I paid £5 for a pint!

So - has Le EFF been in the heady fiduciary world for SO long that he cannot remember such a grave lapse of memory?

IF he has now accepted he IS UNRELIABLE with such MASSIVE sums should he not be removed from office before he does the same but not with SUCH a paltry sum?

Seriously time to GO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by Jon Jon on
Amazing how politicians forget things when it suits them....Le Fondre has always been a ditherer!
Posted by anthony turmel on
AS...IF..a feeble excuse.
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?