Saturday 23 September 2023
Select a region

Ex-Housing Minister aims to force Government hand on housing crisis

Ex-Housing Minister aims to force Government hand on housing crisis

Wednesday 07 April 2021

Ex-Housing Minister aims to force Government hand on housing crisis

Wednesday 07 April 2021

The former Housing Minister is calling for politicians to declare an official ‘housing crisis’ in Jersey and force the Government to act on a report on how to solve it - a document he claims has been “gathering dust” since it was presented to the Chief Minister six months ago.

Senator Sam Mézec’s proposition asks the Government to make all tenancies open-ended, ban rent increases above the inflation rate, cut social housing rents to 80% of the market rate and set up a Rent Tribunal, based on the recommendations from the Housing Policy Development Board.

He explained he had originally planning to publish his proposals after the publication of the report, which was presented to the Chief Minister, Senator John Le Fondré on 16 October.

In a press release, Senator Mézec explained that he had agreed with the Chief Minister he would work on a policy development board “to bring forward a set of wide-ranging proposals to deal with many of the difficult housing issues that successive governments have failed to address” when he agreed to be nominated as Housing Minister.

He added that the report and recommendations had been finalised and presented to the Chief Minister shortly before he resigned as Housing Minister to support the Vote of No Confidence against Senator Le Fondré, in part because of his concerns that he had shown “a lack of commitment to dealing with the housing crisis islanders are facing”.

“The fact that the report has spent almost six months sat on a shelf gathering dust without being published shows that my concerns were well founded,” Senator Mézec said.

After asking “numerous times” when the report would be published, Senator Mézec was told  it would be released by the end of March but when the deadline passed, he decided to make a move in the hope it will “spur on the publication of this important report”.

“I now believe it is in the public interest to force these issues onto the political agenda,” he said.


Pictured: Senator Mézec said the Chief Minister received the report from the Housing Policy Development Board on 16 October.

The proposition offers the States Assembly the opportunity to declare a ‘Housing Affordability Crisis’ in a similar way to how it declared a climate emergency in 2019, which Senator Mézec said will be “an important statement which will show the public how seriously this subject is being taken”.

It also includes five actions for the Government to take to address the issue from legislation to make ‘open-ended’ tenancies standard practice and stabilise rents, to the creation of a Rent Commission or Board to monitor and decide on annual rent increases.

Senator Mézec is also suggesting reducing social housing rents from 90% to 80% of the market rate, and amending the annual financial return provided by Andium Homes to the Treasury so that their housing development programme is not affected.

A timetable for the changes to be implemented, the proposition states, should be produced by the Council of Ministers by the end of July 2021.


Pictured: The graph included in Senator Mézec's proposition shows the cost of rent has been growing at a faster rate than average earnings for the last decade.

“Housing affordability (for both ownership and rental) has been getting steadily worse over recent years,” Senator Mézec wrote in the report accompanying his proposition. “This is inarguable, based on numerous studies that have been undertaken, including the House Price Index, which is produced quarterly, and regularly hits the headlines in the media upon its publication.

"This is not surprising as it is clearly an item of considerable public interest, because of the picture it paints of an Island that is becoming increasingly unaffordable to live in or to plan a future here.”

Senator Mézec said that before his resignation, and in anticipation of the Housing Policy Development Board’s recommendations coming forward, he had secured funding in the Government Plan for their implementation.

“Jersey’s housing market is broken,” he said. “It works too much in the interests of investors, rather than people who need a home. House prices are out of control, aspiring homeowners are constantly outbid by investors and our social housing rents system is putting people in rental stress.

“The Housing Policy Development Board’s recommendations provide a bold way forward which will revolutionise how our housing system meets the needs of ordinary people and realign it to focus on housing as a basic human right, rather than purely a money-making opportunity.

“I hope the government will publish the full Housing Policy Development Board report without further delay and commit to supporting my proposition to deliver on this important work.”

Senator Mézec indicated in his proposition that he will set a date for the debate once the report has been released by the Government to ensure States Members have had time to consider it.

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by David Moon on
What housing crisis. When it is reported that a property has been sold for £31million. Does this not suggest that there is something fundamentally wrong when it is claimed that there is a shortage of 7,000 units of accommodation necessitating the building of housing estates in the countryside and high rise developments in St. Helier. Brown cows in green fields seem to have given way to concrete and tarmac. Which States members had this in their manifesto at the last election?
Posted by Dave Mathews on
Too many Landlords in the States and that is the problem.
We knew about escalating house prices years ago, but we have never seen any enthusiasm from vested interest parties to deal with it.
But we are a year away from an Election so we may see a shake up here.
Posted by Danny Moisan on
time to sell my house then!
Posted by Jon Jon on
You can see an election is coming on the horizon.We all know there isn’t enough housing on this island,allowing Tom ,Dick and Harry in this island with their families has contributed to this.One day the bubble will burst over here.
Posted by Guy de Faye on
It is socially offensive that residents in social housing are currently required to generate additional capital/ notional profit via their rents in order to fund new social housing development. The social housing estate is primarily owned by the public of Jersey and additions to that portfolio should be funded by general taxation.

Social housing rental charges should be based on the quality of the rented premises, together with a share of the cost of ongoing maintenance and the cost of administering the social housing portfolio. None of those elements should, in any way, be linked to the property market or private rental prices.

The "housing crisis" is a direct result of excess population numbers, which Jersey's government continues to ignore. Immigration should be immediately capped at 200 per annum, progressively reducing to zero. Jersey's economic growth policy - based on increasing the population and thus the total tax base - is wholly misguided.

As an example, it is claimed that continued immigration is needed to "support our ageing population". Amazingly, local residents reaching pension age do not suddenly become incapable. Many even wish to continue working and I suggest this should be encouraged by making that specific income free of tax.
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?