Saturday 03 June 2023
Select a region

Hospice: live well and die well - but do it naturally

Hospice: live well and die well - but do it naturally

Thursday 22 March 2018

Hospice: live well and die well - but do it naturally

Thursday 22 March 2018

A Jersey charity tasked with caring for the terminally ill has spoken out against assisted dying, after Guernsey announced controversial steps towards legalising the practice yesterday.

If approved, Guernsey could become the first area in the British Isles to allow its residents to wilfully cut their lives short if suffering from a terminal illness or long-term life-limiting condition.

But palliative care provider Jersey Hospice, which looks after hundreds of dying islanders each year, has now entered the emotive debate, arguing that the focus should be on “the right to die well” rather than the right to die.

“The focus of Jersey Hospice Care now and tomorrow shall always be about the living and living well, right up until the end.

“The European Association of Palliative Care has declared that the provision of euthanasia and assisted dying should not be included in the practice of palliative care – a position that has remained unchanged for 50 years. This is a position that we support,” they said.

Their comments came after the Guernsey government was caught in a media frenzy following misunderstandings over their plans in the national press, leading to fears that approving assisted dying would lead to ‘suicide clinics’ or even ‘suicide tourism’.

assisted dying suicide Guernsey media

Pictured: Some of yesterday's media reports about the assisted dying proposals.

But Deputy Gavin St. Pier – the island’s leading political figure – made assurances that there were no plans for “a Dignitas type solution” following a front page splash in the Daily Mirror highlighted an apparent “shock move” for the “first British suicide clinic”.

He told Express that the headline – similar iterations of which featured on other national news websites – was unfortunate and didn’t properly reflect what was planned locally, adding that assisted dying and assisted suicide were two different things. 

“As ever the headline is rather different to the content of the article. We are not talking about assisted suicide here, we are talking about assisted dying for people who are terminally ill and who have the capacity to make that choice for themselves.”

Deputy St. Pier added that a decision wouldn’t be reached until May at the earliest, with “an awful lot of work left to do.”

While Guernsey’s move has stimulated debate and interest in its sister isle, there are no plans at present for such a law in Jersey. To introduce such plans would be an unlikely move at this stage in time, with under two months before the General Election, and just a few weeks before States Members enter purdah. Speaking in her previous role as Health Minister, Deputy Anne Pryke has previously stated that she was against the idea, while Senator Andrew Green – the incumbent – has not spoken out on the issue.


Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by david forde on
There is room for both. It depends totally on the medical circumstances and pain of the human concerned .
Posted by Elizabeth Johnson on
It is a deeply personal choice. Many people have strong views on this matter and all views should be heard and respected. What is right for one may not be for another. There needs to be checks and balances to protect the vulnerable but is it down to governments to say to people who are terminally ill that they must continue to live with that pain etc if they don’t wish to?
Posted by Sidi Smith on
I totally support the right to choose how to die when the pain and indignity of live become too much. That is 'dying well'.
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?