Thursday 12 December 2024
Select a region
News

Chief Minister seeks power to "suspend" Ministers in "certain circumstances"

Chief Minister seeks power to

Thursday 28 March 2024

Chief Minister seeks power to "suspend" Ministers in "certain circumstances"

Thursday 28 March 2024


The Chief Minister is hoping to introduce legislation which will give him the ability to "suspend" Ministers in "certain circumstances".

Revealing the planned changes in a letter outlining his ministerial and legislative priorities for the year ahead, Deputy Lyndon Farnham explained that, later this year, amendments to the States of Jersey 2025 will be brought forward.

"This would address a current deficiency in the Law, which provides mechanisms to appoint and to dismiss ministers but not to suspend them," he explained.

Screenshot_2024-03-27_at_10.48.47.png

CLICK TO READ IN FULL: A letter from the Chief Minister to the Chair of the Corporate Services Scrutiny Panel.

Any previous occasions involving a suspension of either a Minister or Assistant Minister – such as the suspension of Assistant Minister Montfort Tadier under Chief Minister John Le Fondré – were made by agreement between parties.

However, work is now being undertaken to provide a clear statutory process in the States of Jersey Law for future suspensions.

This work is currently in the policy development phase. However, Express understands that the ability for the Chief Minister to suspend a Minister or Assistant Minister is likely to be triggered only in serious and specific circumstances, such as a criminal investigation and any resulting proceedings.

Montfort_Tadier.jpg

Pictured: Assistant Minister Montfort Tadier was suspended for two months in 2019 after calling for the Hospital's leading pain specialist to be sacked over his views on medicinal cannabis in an email.

Clashes between Ministers came to the fore during Deputy Kristina Moore's time as Chief Minister, with various public clashes with her own Infrastructure Minister Tom Binet, who eventually resigned to call a vote of no confidence which resulted in her becoming the first person in local history to be ousted from the island's top political job at the start of this year.

Deputy Binet accused his former leader of a "complete lack of integrity" and "woeful lack of leadership skill", and in an explosive report described the time serving in her Government as a “depressing affair for many close to the centre of power” which had seen many “heady promises... [fail] to materialise”.

But the spat between the pair stretched back far further than the vote of no confidence.

Deputy Binet broke ranks last March to suggest that the Chief Minister had not been transparent in her communications around former Government CEO Suzanne Wylie's departure.

The Chief Minister later released a set of correspondence that revealed tensions between her and Deputy Binet stretched as far back as October.

Tom_Binet_meeting.jpg

Pictured: The tensions between former Chief Minister Kristina Moore and her Infrastructure Minister Tom Binet stretched back almost a year.

Later in the year, Deputy Binet told States Members during a debate on the controversial creation of a new oversight board for Health that he had been threatened by the Chief Minister that he would be reported to the political behaviour watchdog – the Commissioner for Standards – if he stood up to speak against the motion. Deputy Moore denied that this was a threat.

Deputy Binet was not the only member of Deputy Moore's team to object to the health reform – four others also voted against: Assistant Ministers Steve Ahier, Rose Binet and Richard Vibert, and Assistant Chief Minister Andy Jehan.

During the debate, Constable Jehan went so far as to explain that he had offered to resign due to his disagreement.

This was later referenced in his resignation letter in November, which expressed "severe concerns" about the board, and also fired a broadside at the Health Minister for the apparent lack of "coherent strategy" in Health, as well as her failure to endorse the Government's plans to upgrade the island's health facilities.

READ MORE...

FOCUS: So, who is our new Chief Minister... Deputy Lyndon Farnham?

Farnham appointed as Jersey's new Chief Minister

Former hospital rivals unite in bid to secure new Chief Minister for Jersey

CM challenger misses out on chance at top job by minutes

No Moore: Chief Minister ousted after historic no confidence vote

◆ BLOW-BY-BLOW: The vote of no confidence against Chief Minister Kristina Moore

EXPLAINED: Could Kristina Moore really be toppled?

Binet makes official bid to oust Chief Minister over "woeful" leadership

INSIGHT: How united is Kristina Moore's Government?

Town Constable becomes CM's right-hand man after resignation reshuffle

Politicians demand answers after Assistant CM's parting shot at Health

Assistant CM takes aim at Health Minister in explosive resignation letter

IN FULL: Constable Andy Jehan's resignation letter... and the Chief Minister's response

Concerns over "apparent lack of Ministerial consensus" about hospital plans

"Inexperience" criticism as Assistant Minister blocks £120m town revamp

Minister claims CM tried to gag him over health board concerns

Emails reveal history of tension between Moore and Binet

Minister who broke ranks “considering best way forward”

Was Gov "disingenuous" over CEO resignation or "transparent"?

Sign up to newsletter

 

Comments

Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?