Return of annual dog beach restrictions renews debate

Monday 01 May 2023

It's that time of year again... Summer restrictions for walking dogs and exercising horses on beaches have come into effect.

From today (1 May), dogs are not allowed on beaches without a lead between 10:30 and 18:00.

The restrictions come to an end with the finish of the traditional summer tourist season on 30 September.

The same time limits also apply to horse owners, who are not allowed to exercise their horses on the beach between 10:30 and 18:00 until the restrictions end. 

There is also a £500 fine for not picking up dog mess.

The Government issued a reminder on social media yesterday, commenting: "Let's work together to keep our beaches safe and enjoyable for everyone this summer."

Summer is on its way, and with it comes the annual change in rules for using our beaches in Jersey.

From 1 May to 30 Sept, dogs walked on any of our beaches must be on a lead between 10:30am and 6pm. Additionally, horses cannot be exercised on the beach during these same times. pic.twitter.com/Ula3iPkZfa

— Government of Jersey (@GovJersey) April 30, 2023

The reminder has renewed public debate over whether the annual restrictions remain appropriate, with many labelling them "draconian" and "outdated".

John Hamilton commented on Facebook: "It is unfit for purpose with the demise of tourism and specific areas of beaches should be available to dog owners and horse riders all the time as very few people use them otherwise. Restricting the times actually makes it more dangerous, increasing the likelihood of dog fights or dogs chasing horses which can be extremely dangerous."

However, arguing in favour of the restrictions, Katrina Roby argued: "It's lovely to know that you can go to the beach and not have dogs running up to you. It's not just tourists who like to use the beach without being bothered by off lead dogs. It's about sharing the beach and allowing everyone to enjoy it. Dogs can still be walked on the beach, they just need to be on a lead. I will never understand the mentality of dog owners that feel they should be allowed year round off lead access. Why is sharing a safe beach space such an abhorrent idea?"

In common with many others, Alun Griffiths suggested that "a designated beach should be available to dog owners all day."

Tony Moretta said on Twitter: "I do agree with others now that some beaches, away from the tourist areas, should be left free of these restrictions as there are few places in Jersey where dogs can be let off the leash to have a run. Has anyone actually looked at this @GovJersey?"

However, local conservationist Stephen Le Quesne pointed out that there may be an impact on wildlife from changing the rules.

"Many local and migrating bird species use our beaches as places of rest and to refuel. Dogs chasing them causes stress and lower breeding success," he explained.