Wednesday 12 June 2024
Select a region

Son who stabbed mother felt "connection" to parents' annexe

Son who stabbed mother felt

Friday 26 April 2024

Son who stabbed mother felt "connection" to parents' annexe

Friday 26 April 2024

A man who stabbed his mother to death in her home felt like he had a "spiritual connection" to his parents' annexe meaning that requests for him to move out "precipitated a meltdown", an inquest has heard.

Pamela Nisbet, a 68-year-old former honorary police officer, died after being attacked on 5 August 2019 in the kitchen of her St Peter home by her son Andrew Nisbet.

Nisbet faced the Royal Court a year after his mother’s death, when he admitted manslaughter on the basis of diminished responsibility and was sentenced to remain in a secure psychiatric hospital.

An inquest into the death of Mrs Nisbet resumed earlier this week.

Yesterday the inquest was told that Nisbet – who had severe autism spectrum disorder and Asperger syndrome – had jumped out of a two-storey window, injuring both his legs, following a disagreement with his father.

And he had said that if he was evicted from the annexe to his parents’ home where he was living he would kill himself.

But a psychiatric nurse told the inquest that Nisbet never gave any indication that he was going to harm anyone else.

Pamela Nisbet.png

Pictured: Pamela Nisbet, a 68-year-old former honorary police officer, died after being attacked by her son on 5 August 2019.

Nisbet had moved to Jersey from the UK with his partner and infant son in November 2017 and was allowed to live temporarily in the annexe to his parents’ house.

Community psychiatric nurse Ronan Mulhern told the inquest that Nisbet’s autism and Asperger syndrome were known about but there had been no signs of clinical depression or psychiatric illness.

He added: “At no stage did Andrew say anything. There was no history of violence.”

However, his mental health had deteriorated after moving to Jersey and his parents eventually felt he should move out of the annexe – even buying a three-bedroom house where he and his family could live for a low rent.

He refused to move and asked his parents to make alterations to the annexe, which they declined to do.

When his father, Pat, refused to install a heat pump in the annexe, Nisbet jumped out of the second-floor window, injuring himself.

Mr Mulhern said Nisbet had become “fixated with the idea that it was his permanent home”. He said: “He had a spiritual connection to the property.”

Of the request to move out, he said: “It increased Andrew’s feelings of rejection and precipitated a meltdown.

"He said he would rather die than go anywhere else."

Mr Mulhern said there was no sign of a plan to harm anyone else.

However, in the weeks before the eviction police were repeatedly called to the parents’ house and they became concerned for the safety of Nisbet’s father.

Five days after the eviction he killed his mother.

The inquest is due to conclude next week.


GP went “above and beyond” to help son who later stabbed mother

Inquest resumes into mother's death after being stabbed by her son

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?