Saturday 19 September 2020
Select a region

WATCH: Jersey planning ‘travel bubble’ with UK

WATCH: Jersey planning ‘travel bubble’ with UK

Monday 11 May 2020

WATCH: Jersey planning ‘travel bubble’ with UK


Jersey is investigating allowing restriction-free travel in and out of the UK, it has been confirmed – despite the Health Minister previously describing opening the borders as “our greatest risk."

The government had previously hinted that unlocking travel to and from the island would be the final step in its lockdown exit plan – in common with Guernsey – and could come as late as 2021.

But now that position appears to have changed. 

Asked about the concept of a ‘travel bubble’ by Express at a press conference last week, the Chief Minister admitted that the move was under consideration by the Scientific, Technical and Advisory Committee (STAC).

Medical Director Patrick Armstrong, who forms part of STAC, said that it had been specifically discussed last Wednesday, noting that some changes to travel may be “out of our control”, as they depend on other jurisdictions.

travelcoronaviruscovid19suitcasesairport.jpg

Pictured: The UK wants to exempt travellers from the Channel Islands and Isle of Man from 14 days of compulsory quarantine when it reopens its travel links.

But, before any decision is made, he said: “We need a lot more information to come to us and a lot more time to look at the practicalities and what it means and the risks that are involved.”

The ‘UK travel bubble’ concept further solidified over the weekend, as the Times reported that the UK – whose covid-19 death toll is now higher than most European countries – will be exempting travellers from the Channel Islands and Isle of Man from having to self-isolate for 14 days after arrival.

However, it remains unclear whether Jersey and Guernsey would be expected to reciprocate the self-isolation exemption in return for free travel. 

When Express put the question to the Chief Minister, Senator John Le Fondré, he declined to answer, maintaining that there is “no change” to travel arrangements as Jersey moves down to ‘Level Three’ – so-called ‘Soft Lockdown’ – in the ‘Safe Exit Framework’.

Video: The Chief Minister answered questions from Express about travel at a press conference this morning.

“As of today, there is no difference in travel arrangements, and essentially we are waiting for that piece of work to be brought together and then being brought up to the Ministers. Other than that, at this stage, I can’t make any further comment,” he said.

“Once we have seen that piece of advice and obviously considered it in the light of the medical advice we get, we’ll make some announcements but we are not going to speculate at this stage. There is no change as of today on the travel advice, which basically there is only essential travel coming to the island and for compassionate purposes.”

While Level Three still contains a requirement for travellers arriving in the island to self-isolate for 14 days, there is no such restriction listed on Level Two of the lockdown exit plan.

Asked to address this point, the Chief Minister replied: “We know we are going to have to consider it because at that some point if we do move down to Level Two - we don’t know when that will be yet - we want the factors to consider it. And, don’t forget, it may not be on day one on Level Two – it might be further down the process.

“So, it’s always going to be about our assessment of the first steps we go through, where we are and the impact those steps have been. We are day one of easing into Level Three - focus on that today. There is no change in the travel arrangements."

airporttaxi.jpg

Pictured: The Chief Minister declined to comment about what travel relationship Jersey and the UK are likely to have in Level Two.

Currently, islanders can only travel via Blue Islands to the mainland with government permission for reasons such as essential work, medical treatment or other compassionate reasons. Routine work or leisure travel remains prohibited.

The UK's consideration of allowing restriction-free travel comes as aviation sector representatives warned that 14-day quarantines as more routine travel reopens - currently expected to occur at the end of this month or early June - would devastate their industry.

Meanwhile, in Jersey, some multi-jurisdiction businesses are anxious for travel to resume so that they can restart normal service and continue to meet clients and stakeholders abroad.

For Deputy Jess Perchard, easing into Level Three lockdown and talk of a travel bubble with the UK when covid-19 still remains active on the island is a source of frustration, particularly as she had raised questions at an early stage.

"The day that States members were told that there was a case of coved-19 in Jersey, I went to a senior Minister to share my views. I said that, in my opinion, we could have zero deaths in Jersey if you handle this the right way," she told Express.

jess_perchard_states_assembly.jpg

Pictured: Deputy Jess Perchard said she would have liked to see a pan-island travel bubble - if the island first got its covid-19 numbers down to zero.

"Why don't you lockdown the island right now for three weeks whilst we figure out how to shut this down and figure out how to live in a sustainable way and continue to receive imports in a low-risk manner? We could have been a coronavirus-free zone, meaning that we could leave everything open and people could move freely on-island.

"If other islands did the same thing, we could have allowed movement between those places too. This perspective was dismissed as unrealistic. I was told that it's impossible to prevent the spread of the virus and that people would die."

She continued: "New Zealand has had fewer deaths than we have, and that is because front the start, that has been the aim.

"In an exam, if you aim for an 'A' you are more likely to get a 'B' than if you aim for a 'C'. If you aim for zero deaths, you will have fewer deaths than If you don't aim for zero deaths. What is the Government's ambition?"

Sign up to newsletter

 

Comments

Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by PaulBurton51 on
This is an interesting subject but I believe Jess is missing some obvious issues.

Students will be going to university and they come home at half term
In many cases they will go across in late August to arrange, move in to accomodation with their parents
My fiance is in Germany . Need to see her .
My cousin works in London and is due to go back in July. She works 3 weeks then has a week off, so comes back for a week before returning (most of the time)
Jersey people have relatives in the UK and there are thousands that want to, do, make a long weekend trip . There can't be a 14 day penalty for those visits
All those with holidays booked from last year or early this year for later in summer or autumn will need to go if uK allows flights to the destinations otherwise insurance won't pay out if only Jersey had a quarantine and then they can't take an extra 2 weeks off work.

Just some examples on why 14 day won't work when flights start.
Posted by Janette Gabrielsson on
I found Paul Burton’s comment to be patronising to Jess Perchard in assuming that she was missing some obvious issues. I believe that you are in fact missing the point: as an island wi5 control over its borders, we are in a position to contain the spread of the virus by closing our borders to the extent that they are already closed. If Jersey residents wish to travel to the U.K. or elsewhere to go to university, they should do so in the knowledge that they will not be able to travel back and forth freely and, absolutely, not without having to self isolate for 14 days. As it stands, it is not even certain that any universities will be open or accepting non-UK resident students. If people in long-distance relationships cannot manage the separation, one of them should move to the other’s jurisdiction for the duration of the pandemic rather than putting other people’s life at risk.
Posted by Alan Keen on
It seems odd that the Isle of Wight is only allowing essential visitors in and Jersey want to allow a free for all. It would appear that the Government of Jersey are living in a bubble.
Posted by David Moon on
Deputy Jess Perchard was quite right that it should have been done at day one with an island wide testing programme. The latest joke is the announcement to abandon the testing programme and guessing how many people have contracted Covid 19 on the basis of a sample of 150 people.
Posted by Jon Jon on
Open up travelling to uk via airport,ports,opens up a can of worms,we all know before this lockdown people travelling back to the island did not self isolate as they were meant to do.Had they ,maybe the island would of faired better.
Posted by Alex Fisher on
Paul is completely right.

Given their performance to date I think it is reasonable to allow the CM and Health Minister a little trust here. I doubt very much that they are planning to open the floodgates and proclaim a big summer tourist season. But I think they recognise, as they should, that the idea of locking a small island off from the world until and unless a vaccine is found is palpably absurd. How long should we wait?

For the foreseeable future, we are going to have to learn to live in a world where the virus exists. We've already shown that we are able to control the virus on the island. With the right mix of health screening at points of entry, potentially at-port testing where needed, and careful limits on the number of flights I am confident we can find a sensible balance that allows those Islanders whose closest family live on the mainland to see them. Those who visit will have to abide by the same rules that everyone else is abiding by. If 14-day self-isolation is mandated there simply won't be enough demand to maintain routine transport links to the island.

There's a grey area between shipping in thousands of tourists to party at the Yacht on a Friday night and not allowing Islanders to see their families and friends for the next eighteen months. I'm sure we can find it if we try, rather than surrendering to isolation for an indefinite period.
Posted by Scott Mills on
why not just fly to budapest or is it bucharest? ask a politician for the answer.
Posted by Peter Brookes on
Total lunacy. We must NOT allow travel from the UK until the UK has sorted out it's corona virus issues, unless travellers pay to be quarantined in a government guarded facility, such as a requisitioned hotel or the Nightingale!
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?