Concerns over a “complex and fragmented” approach to regulation in Jersey that has left potential regulatory gaps, duplication and created difficulties in assuring value for money have been raised by the island’s public spending watchdog.
In her new report, released today, Comptroller and Auditor General Lynn Pamment concluded that “Jersey does not have a coherent approach to designing and implementing regulation”.
But the C&AG acknowledged that, at the time of her audit, the island “had no established criteria or framework against which to make decisions about what to regulate and how”.

Ms Pamment also noted that the creation of Senator Boleat’s ministerial role earlier this year has “provided a single point of regulatory leadership”.
“The government is developing an ambitious programme to introduce an evidence‑based framework for regulation,” she added.
“This provides an opportunity to redefine regulation around the minimum assurance requirements needed to minimise harm and protect the public interest.
“Developing an evidence- and risk-based approach also provides the opportunity to
ensure regulation in Jersey is proportionate, targeted, consistent and accountable.”
In many cases regulation has been reactive, created in isolation of other regulation
Comptroller and Auditor General Lynn Pamment
The C&AG’s audit looked at whether there were overlaps or gaps in the design of regulation to effectively achieve public policy aims.
Among the key findings outlined in Ms Pamment’s report is that: “In many cases regulation has been reactive, created in isolation of other regulation.”
She continued: “This has resulted in ‘layering’ of regulations and potential areas of regulatory duplication.
“In comparison with other jurisdictions, Jersey also has some areas where there are potential gaps in regulation.”
Ms Pamment concluded that the island “does not have a coherent approach to designing and implementing regulation”, adding that “the landscape is complex and fragmented and does not allow for the delivery of value for money to be assured”.
