Jersey Electricity’s hopes for a “critical” new substation to be built in promenade gardens in Gorey have failed to generate planning approval after residents objected to the “eyesore” proposal.

In a statement accompanying the application – which garnered nearly 100 public comments – the utility company and the Parish of St Martin contended that a new substation was vital to resolve an issue with the current electrical supply load in the Gorey Harbour area, which is at “full capacity”.

“Jersey Electricity is no longer able to offer any new moderately sized service connections or upgrades in the area,” the statement noted, describing the proposed location as “the best available site for the substation” given its proximity to the existing network and supplies.

It proposed that the structure could be concealed with a trellis cloaked with planting – but acknowledged this would still have a “minor negative impact” on the setting.

Pictured: It had been proposed that the structure could be concealed by planting (Jersey Electricity & Parish of St Martin planning statement).

It also argued that the inclusion of a bin store could mitigate issues with smells and rats stemming from bins in the pedestrian area at the bottom of the hill.

But residents raised a number of objections, many of which centred around concerns that the substation would be “an eyesore that is wholly out of keeping with the character of the area”.

Several objectors expressed confusion as to how the proposal had reached the planning application stage.

One islander commented that they were “at a loss to understand why this was ever considered to be appropriate”, while another said that the promenade was “not the place for such an eyesore and ugly installation”.

Permission to build the substation was refused.

The notice outlining the planning refusal also concluded that the development would have had “an unacceptable visual impact”.

“Due to its design, scale and siting, the proposal fails to protect the special interest and detracts from the significance of the Grade 1 listed Gorey Harbour and Mont Orgueil Castle, and other listed buildings along Gorey Pier,” it stated.

Reacting to the decision, a JE spokesperson told Express that the utility company was “reviewing its next steps” and would “seek further input from parish and planning officials once the complex siting and engineering issues have been explored further”.

“We fully recognise the sensitivity of the location and undertook extensive design and consultation work with both parish and planning officials to mitigate visual and environmental impacts,” the spokesperson said.

“The current network simply cannot support additional demand from the hotels, restaurants and residential properties in the Gorey Pier area, unless a substation is constructed within 200 metres of the Gorey Pier and coach park area.”

Among those to strongly oppose the application was former States Deputy Jennifer Bridge, who wrote a blog dedicated to the matter arguing that more needed to be done to safeguard Gorey for future generations.

“Given that the last time the port saw significant funding was over 200 years ago when the States of Jersey invested £16,000 (equivalent to £1.6m – £1.9m today) to rebuild the pier between 1815 and 1817, is it hyperbolic to suggest that we are on the cusp of a once in a lifetime opportunity to get this right and that a pause to these plans in the grand scheme of things represents an opportunity to set a new standard befitting the significance of this area?” she wrote.

“Today, Gorey’s importance remains, not only as a tourist destination but as a vital part of Jersey’s identity. Securing its future requires collaboration between government and non-governmental organisations to develop a cohesive strategy that revitalises the harbour area while preserving its heritage.

“Bringing stakeholders together through structured discussions would allow for a reassessment of responsibilities and exploration of cost-effective, innovative solutions. A unified vision as opposed to a silo mentality will ensure efficient use of resources, while modernising infrastructure, harmonising aesthetics, and enhancing visitor experiences.”

She added that a ‘Port Summit’ at Mont Orgueil Castle with the objective of creating a Port Custodians’ Charter – led by key stakeholders – “could serve as the catalyst for meaningful change as long as delivery underpins the process by fostering a balanced approach that respects history while embracing necessary improvements, Gorey Harbour can continue to thrive as a treasured landmark for generations to come”.