The government has rejected calls to check whether recommendations arising from the Covid pandemic were signed off prematurely, arguing that reviewing closed actions would take disproportionate resources.
But the Public Accounts Committee has challenged that decision, saying the response does not provide “sufficient assurance” and urging the government to reconsider.
The committee had recommended that the chief executive consider a review by the end of 2026 to establish whether any recommendations had been closed too soon and take appropriate action.
But in a response published today, the government said all recommendations from pandemic reviews had already been monitored through its corporate tracking process.
It acknowledged that this process “does not validate the implementation of every recommendation”, instead checking whether the reasons given for closing them appear reasonable.
The government argued that the committee’s own review had not identified specific issues, questioning the proportionality of revisiting a large number of closed actions “given the resource this would require”.
It also said Covid recommendations had been incorporated into its Crisis Resilience Improvement Plan and highlighted stronger collaboration with the UK and other jurisdictions.
The committee said resource and proportionality concerns “should not preclude an appropriate review from being undertaken”.
The response also addresses Jersey’s readiness for future emergencies, including whether it holds sufficient financial reserves to withstand a significant shock to the financial services sector.
The government rated the risk associated with inadequate reserves as “extreme”, warning that insufficient funds could leave public finances unsustainable, particularly during a crisis.
However, it stressed that decisions on reserve levels rest with ministers and ultimately the States Assembly, while officials would continue to advise a prudent approach.
A review of public services, due by the end of July 2027, will develop options to reduce costs and duplication, potentially freeing money for reserves.
Meanwhile, the government agreed in principle with calls for more emergency exercises, but said this work was already taking place.
Exercises are prioritised according to risk and likelihood, with additional scenarios to be recommended where appropriate.
The committee acknowledged progress on emergency exercises and financial resilience, saying it would consider whether further follow-up was needed.
