Does disagreement with government policy influence how willing we are to engage constructively with the people contributing to Guernsey’s economy?
There is something rather disheartening about trying to promote Guernsey, champion an emerging local film industry and encourage economic development, only to find that the exciting opportunities emerging for Guernsey’s growing industry had been overshadowed by an unnecessary, and seemingly personal, reference to the recent GST debate
This recent exchange with Guernsey’s Committee for Economic Development has left me questioning whether we are always as welcoming and encouraging of local entrepreneurial ambition as we like to think.
It began innocently enough. Having come across a BBC article about Jersey’s interest to develop its screen industry through film incentives, I shared it with the Committee, accompanied by a light-hearted suggestion that I hoped Guernsey would stay ahead of our island neighbours. After all, there is nothing wrong with a little friendly rivalry, particularly when it could benefit our own economy.
I also took the opportunity to share some positive news about Guernsey’s film industry. Having just returned from the American Film Market in Los Angeles, where we had secured international distribution for one of our upcoming films, which was shot entirely in Guernsey and has now been sold to multiple international territories.
I also mentioned that there would be further exciting developments to share in the coming months.
The response I received was somewhat unexpected.
Rather than acknowledging these developments or the efforts being made to promote Guernsey’s screen industry, the response focused on explaining how much work was already being undertaken by the Committee and, rather unnecessarily, brought my public opposition to the introduction of GST into the conversation.

Apparently, following the tax reform debate, the Committee now thinks it has greater financial certainty and the ability to consider new economic development initiatives.
I have no issue with the Committee explaining its ambitions or the work it is undertaking. What I do question is why my political position on GST was considered relevant to an otherwise positive and entirely unrelated exchange.
Political disagreement should not become a professional barrier
Many people will already be familiar with my public opposition to the introduction of GST, in all its proposed forms, and my involvement in organising activities and protests against it.
I have also been openly critical of the way in which what I consider to be serious alternative proposals have been effectively guillotined, rather than being given the opportunity to form part of what should have been a genuine and meaningful democratic debate. Surely, if alternatives are being requested by P&R, they should also be given a fair and meaningful opportunity to be considered and debated.
I make no apology for holding those views or for having exercised my right to campaign and speak publicly on an issue that I believe has significant implications for Guernsey, its residents and its businesses.That is precisely what democratic participation is about: being able to question government policy, challenge decisions and put forward alternative perspectives.
However, none of that should have any bearing on my willingness to support initiatives that could benefit Guernsey, nor should it influence how those contributions are received by the very committee tasked with developing the island’s economy.
What I found particularly disappointing was the specific wording used in the Committee’s response: “Following the recent tax reform debate, which I understand you strongly and publicly opposed, we now have greater certainty and the ability to consider new economic development initiatives.”
I have no difficulty with the Committee explaining that the outcome of the tax reform debate has given it greater financial certainty and potentially more scope to pursue economic development initiatives. That is a perfectly reasonable point to make.
But why was it necessary to add the personal observation about my opposition to GST?

The sentence would have conveyed precisely the same information without those words. The inclusion added nothing to the explanation, contributed nothing to the discussion about film incentives and served no practical purpose in communicating the Committee’s intentions.
Instead, it introduced an entirely unnecessary personal and political dimension into what had been a positive and constructive exchange. I find that particularly disappointing from a committee whose responsibility should be to promote and encourage economic development across the island.
Surely, whether someone agrees or disagrees with a particular government policy should have no bearing on how their entrepreneurial efforts, commercial activities or contributions to Guernsey are received.
Disagreement is not disloyalty, and opposing a government policy should not somehow make someone less worthy of constructive engagement.
Recognise the people already doing the work
For context, I am a committee member of the Institute of Screen Arts Guernsey (ISAG), and have been actively involved in building Guernsey’s local film industry since I first set foot on the island.
I am very much up to date with the activities, projects and achievements of fellow filmmakers and producers. I also actively support other productions wherever and however I can, as I firmly believe that building a sustainable film industry is a collective effort and that we all benefit from supporting one another and growing the creative community as a whole.
For the past five years, I have also organised the GUERNSEY FILM FEST, an initiative that promotes Guernsey as a film destination and has not cost the States of Guernsey a single penny. The latest edition attracted an increased number of visitors from the UK and Jersey, bringing additional visitors and economic activity to the island.
Behind the scenes, I am also working to attract at least one, and potentially two, American productions to shoot in Guernsey. If successful, these would represent a first for the island and a significant opportunity to bring international production investment, employment and associated economic benefits to our shores.
Alongside this, my own film production activities continue to generate international exposure for Guernsey, with productions filmed here reaching audiences and markets overseas.
These are all practical efforts, involving considerable time, personal investment, commercial relationships and entrepreneurial initiative. And this is precisely why the response from the Committee was so disappointing.
GST and the reality for local businesses
There is also a wider economic point worth considering. The Committee’s reference to the greater financial certainty, following the tax reform debate, appears intended to suggest that the outcome of those reforms will provide greater scope for economic development initiatives.
However, discussions and development work around potential film incentives in Guernsey were already taking place well before GST was approved. The initiative was not conceived as a result of GST, nor should its development be presented as though it depended on it.
I would argue that supporting Guernsey’s creative industries should be an ambition in its own right, rather than something that needs to be justified as a benefit of an entirely separate tax policy.
Economic development is not a political privilege
Guernsey’s creative industries are still in their infancy, particularly when it comes to attracting international film and television productions.
They need encouragement, ambition, investment and, above all, a supportive environment in which they can grow. The people working in these industries are doing that without government funding or any guarantee of commercial success. They are taking risks, building relationships, developing projects and putting Guernsey on the map. That should be something to encourage.
The Committee for Economic Development has an important role to play, but economic development cannot simply be driven by government initiatives, policy papers and funding programmes. It also depends on engaging constructively with the entrepreneurs, business owners, investors and creative professionals who are already contributing to the island’s economy.
And that engagement should extend to everyone, regardless of their political opinions, voting history or position on individual government policies.

I have consistently supported Guernsey’s film industry and its wider economic development ambitions, including working constructively with previous committees. My enthusiasm for the island and its potential has never depended on who happens to be in government.
I would hope that the same principle applies in return.
We should be creating an environment where people feel comfortable bringing forward ideas, sharing successes and contributing to the island’s future, without feeling that their political views might influence how they are treated or whether their contributions are taken seriously.
After all, the Committee is called the Committee for Economic Development. Its responsibility should be to encourage economic opportunity across Guernsey. And if we genuinely want Guernsey to compete with Jersey and attract new industries, perhaps we should start by ensuring that professional engagement, mutual respect and constructive dialogue remain at the heart of how we work together.
Economic development should be about what we can achieve for Guernsey, not whether we happen to agree on everything politically.
Lars Janssen
Filmmaker & Producer – Guernsey Filmworks
