Friday 23 February 2024
Select a region

Police asked to investigate as new evidence emerges in baby death case

Police asked to investigate as new evidence emerges in baby death case

Monday 04 September 2023

Police asked to investigate as new evidence emerges in baby death case

Monday 04 September 2023

Police have been asked to undertake further investigations into a baby's death on Jersey's maternity ward in 2018 after it emerged that references to "bad feeling" among staff were removed from a witness statement.

Reference to an "incident" the evening before the birth of Amelia Clyde-Smith which led to ill feeling among a maternity team – the same team that was on shift when Amelia was born – was included in a statement given by a member of that team after Amelia’s death.

Statement changed upon request

However, it emerged at a pre-inquest hearing this morning that this reference had later been removed from the statement submitted to the Viscount’s Department.

This was something done at the request of another member of Health staff, those at the hearing were told.

It meant that the Coroner was unaware of this potentially relevant information and only became aware of it in July this year.

Police probe and plan for an independent investigation

The Relief Coroner overseeing the inquest, Bridget Dolan KC, has subsequently asked the police to gather additional witness statements and assess if there is any criminal liability. 

The police are yet to finish that process.

Health is also launching an independent investigation to find out more details about the incident that led to the bad feeling among staff, whether it may have had a bearing on Amelia’s care, which Health has already conceded was not to standard, and why references to it were removed from the witness statement.


Pictured: The Relief Coroner asked police officers to gather additional evidence and assess if there is any criminal liability.

However, that investigation is yet to be commissioned and a suitable independent person to lead it yet to be selected – hence, the inquest into Amelia’s death, which was earmarked for this January, has been pushed back to April.

Health also needs time to respond to the independent investigation and take action, if required.

Inquest delayed

At the pre-inquest hearing on Monday, Ms Dolan apologised to Amelia’s parents, Dominic and Ewelina Clyde-Smith, for the delay but added that it was important that she knew more about the 'bad feeling' incident in order to assess its relevance to the cause of Amelia’s death, which she is charged with determining.

Amelia suffered brain damage and died in September 2018 aged one month. In 2019, Health apologised to Mr and Mrs Clyde-Smith, admitting that her death was “probably” avoidable.


Pictured: The hearing took place this morning at International House.

The apology followed an investigation by the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, which found that there were “missed opportunities with management of maternal observations” after complications with the birth were recognised and that there was “an absence of a proper escalation policy” once things started to go wrong.

A report issued as a result of the inquiry made a series of recommendations, which included improving “candour” with patients and developing an “escalation policy”.

It added that investigators could not be certain that an alternative course of actions would have resulted in a different outcome.

Mr and Mrs Clyde-Smith question if Health would have investigated their daughter’s death had they not battled for it to happen.

Another pre-inquest review hearing has been scheduled for February, before April’s full inquest.

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?