Wednesday 08 July 2020
Select a region

Government “missed opportunity” to protect islanders

Government “missed opportunity” to protect islanders

Friday 13 March 2020

Government “missed opportunity” to protect islanders

A senior doctor has slammed the government for “missing an opportunity to protect islanders” from coronavirus after the Chief Minister said people should still take holidays off-island.

The criticism from cardiologist Dr Andrew Mitchell came after Ministers unveiled a package of measures to address the Covid-19 outbreak following a four-hour meeting of the Emergencies Council last night.

Those included funding for urgent health checks on vulnerable islanders and tax breaks for struggling businesses, but the decision was not taken to restrict large-scale events, close schools or urge against non-essential travel.

Video: The Chief Minister's opening speech to the Emergencies Council. 

“I am asking Islanders to maintain a measured semblance of normal life and this includes taking holidays off-island,” Chief Minister Senator John Le Fondré said.  

“Although our priority is to protect the community from coronavirus, the Government will be looking after the interests of public money sensibly.” 

The comments sparked a furious backlash on social media, coming just hours after Guernsey’s Public Health Service took the opposite position, “strongly advising” against travel off-island. 

“Go home and stay there. This is not just about you, it’s everyone else, especially the vulnerable. We have to work as a community,” Guernsey’s Chief Minister, Gavin St. Pier, urged. 

Cardiologist Dr Andrew Mitchell hit out at Jersey’s position as “astonishing” on Twitter, opting to issue his own “different” advice to patients. 

“Don’t travel. If you are elderly then limit social contact to essentials. Work from home,” he wrote. 

“If they have got it wrong then things are really bad,” Dr Mitchell added in the post that has since gained over 200 ‘likes’ and around 100 retweets.

In the wake of the news, a petition calling for the island to be put on ‘lockdown’ hit 2,000 signatures, and continues to grow. 

Responding to the waves of disapproval this morning, Senator Le Fondré tweeted: “We have been advised by the Medical Officer that the island at present does not need to be locked down and we need to enable islanders to retain normal activities.

"If you seek to travel, you should first check the current UK [Foreign Commonwealth Office] guidelines.” 

Last night, the Health Minister, Deputy Richard Renouf, maintained the government was “committed to protecting our most vulnerable”, adding that islanders should still be able to socialise unhindered if they do not have cold or flu-like symptoms. 

“However, for some, a level of social distancing may be required which would mean they should not attend social events or gather in groups until further advice is issued. We will keep Islanders updated regarding this advice,” he said.

Hours after that advice was issued, Economic Development Minister Senator Lyndon Farnham announced plans to protect the island’s economy as Covid-19 takes hold. 

These included: 

  • Deferring the payment of social security contributions;
  • The deferral of GST payments;
  • Considering payment deferrrals where the Government is a landlord to a local business (directly or through a Government-owned company);
  • And supporting Jersey Business with top-up funding. 

Senator Farnham also confirmed there was “support” from the local banking sector. 

Yesterday, NatWest announced loan repayment ‘holidays’ for its personal and SME clients, among other measures.


Pictured: NatWest International has announced a raft of emergency support measures for customers and small and medium sized businesses.

Businesses across the island are clamping down on non-essential travel and visits to public gatherings and increasingly advising staff to work remotely.

This week’s Chamber Lunch was held ‘virtually’, while Jersey’s Institute of Directors as chosen to cancel its next meeting. 

Numerous local care homes are now taking the decision to restrict visitors to protect their residents.

St. Helier-based St. Ewold's was the latest to do so this morning, explaining: “Whilst appreciating the inconvenience that this will undoubtedly cause, we feel that taking this precautionary measure now is in the best interests of our residents."


Pictured: St. Ewold's this morning announced it would be restricting visits to the care home.

“The St. Ewold’s Team will discuss the practicalities of how this will work with residents, family and friends," they added.

There are still only two cases of coronavirus that have been officially confirmed on the island.

Both individuals had recently returned from Italy and remain in self-isolation.

The illness was this week declared a pandemic by the World Health Organisation, but they noted this related to the transmissibility of Covid-19, rather than the severity of it, with around 80% of cases said to be 'mild'.

For more information about coronavirus, including the list of affected countries and advice on when to self-isolate, click HERE.


Funding released for urgent health checks on elderly islanders and those with chronic conditions

Hundreds call for 'lockdown' as coronavirus fears grow

Second coronavirus case in Jersey officially confirmed

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Jon Needham on
I think the CM has been badly advised. Suggesting people increases the risk and the problems we may need to manage ie repatriation. Travel insurance cover is also likely invalid. I think he would be well advised to follow Dr Mitchell’s advice and the example of our French neighbours.
Posted by T Hanson on
The Channel Islands are unlike the UK and the approach could have been different. As small Islands, each of the Channel Islands could stand a chance of batting off the virus for some time until much later in the year if travel in and out were restricted to essential travel at the outset, and measures were put in place to quarantine those coming in for preferably 14 days and for testing. Later down the line there might be a medical breakthrough at least in treatment. It seems more sensible to have some limited disruption at the early stage, which would still in the main enable normal activities to carry on in the Islands, rather than have to lock everything down,disrupt business and close schools when the virus cannot then be contained in a month or two. Buying some time is precious.
Posted by Terence Roger Tanner on
Sorry but it’s down to the individual to assess if they go on holiday I believe it’s very hard after living in this money orientated Island forget the elderly and the sick if they catch it we will save money on pensions and support it’s a win for the government to do and say as little as possible to keep us informed as a person in the vulnerable area I am of a mind if it’s my time the Lord has set for me I place my life in his arms God bless us all ????????
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?