Thursday 25 February 2021
Select a region

Jersey tries to calm stormy waters over “very worrying” fishing fallout

Jersey tries to calm stormy waters over “very worrying” fishing fallout

Monday 18 January 2021

Jersey tries to calm stormy waters over “very worrying” fishing fallout

Jersey has been trying to calm troubled waters over fishing rights this weekend by explaining that its hands have been tied by the UK and EU.

A diplomatic storm has blown up over the right of French boats to fish in Jersey’s territorial waters. It even prompted France’s Minister for the Sea to say that the country was “getting ready for battle” and lobbying Brussels to get Jersey removed from the recently signed UK/EU trade deal.

She, along with fishing representatives in France, are saying that Jersey is refusing to abide by the new treaty by not licensing boats from Normandy and Brittany, who historically have been able to fish up to three miles off Jersey.

The tussle even made the national news this weekend, with the Daily Express reporting that Jersey had “hung up” on the French regarding talks and had decided to “stop the interim system” currently in place.

Environment Minister John Young, however, said that this couldn’t be further from the truth.

French fishing boat trawler.png

Pictured: Under the UK/EU trade deal, Jersey takes back full licensing control of its waters.

“We are in a very tense and worrying situation because if this part of the deal is rejected, it all falls away for Jersey, including tariff-free trade,” he said.

“The External Relations Minister had a conversation with the French on Friday and my Assistant Minister Gregory Guida spoke to the French media on Sunday to explain our position.”

Deputy Young said that Jersey had proposed an interim arrangement after the UK/EU deal had been signed which would honour existing licences - issued under the Bay of Granville Agreement, which was superseded by the new deal - for a four-month period.

“We recognised that we have a long and valuable relationship with the French, so we wanted to give both them and us time to implement the new licensing regime,” he said. 

Jersey territorial waters.jpeg

Pictured: Jersey’s territorial waters stretch out to 12 miles of the mean water mark, with licensed French boats allowed within three miles of the Island

“However, we received a clear message from the UK and EU that they wanted no interim arrangements and the terms of the trade deal should be followed to the letter and introduced straight away.”

That deal gave Jersey full licensing powers over its territorial waters but with the proviso that French boats could still fish up to three miles and existing licences had to be honoured - providing that it could be proved that each licensed boat had fished in the area on at least 10 occasions in any one year between 2017 and 2020.

“When we asked the EU for that proof, we were simply sent a list of about 350 boats, which we knew was generic and not up to date,” said Deputy Young. 

“But being proactive and wanting to be helpful, we issued licences to about 60 French boats which, through our own records, we knew were legitimate and met the criteria.”

Deputy Young added that he was encouraging all French fishermen with a licence under the Bay of Granville Agreement to send their evidence, as set out in the new agreement, to Jersey as soon as they could. 

Under the deal - which was agreed by Brussels and London on Christmas Eve and backed by the States the following Sunday - both sides have 90 days to walk away if they don’t like the terms that relate to Jersey.


Pictured: Environment Minister John Young: “We know we have to implement the new agreement fairly, objectively and indiscriminately”.

The fear for Jersey is that the French convince the EU to enact that clause, which means that the Island falls out of the deal, tariffs apply to Jersey produce (but not the UK) and the Bay of Granville Agreement returns.

However, Deputy Young said that Jersey has been clear in its view that the Bay of Granville agreement, before it was replaced, had swung far too much in favour of the French, who were not only increasingly fishing in Jersey’s waters but also failing to adhere to its provisions about conservation, such as accurately recording what they were catching and where it was caught. 

The Bay of Granville Agreement, which was signed in 2000 and formalised a 182-year-old convention of shared fishing grounds, allowed French boats to fish up to Jersey’s three-mile limit, in exchange for Jersey boats being able to fish closer to France. However, it is understood that those French waters have become unproductive, prompting increased fishing around Jersey.

“We know we have to implement the new agreement fairly, objectively and indiscriminately,” said Deputy Young. “We also know that our own fishermen and merchants have encountered massive bureaucratic problems when they’ve tried to land produce in France. We are doing all we can to resolve this tricky situation.”

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by IanSmith97 on
Is anybody surprised? It’s what French farmers and fishermen do when their God given entitlements are threatened, changed or challenged.
Posted by David Moon on
Why does Jersey turn this to its advantage by requesting the EU to reinstate the terms of Protocal 3 to the Treaty of accession putting us back in the position we were with tariff free trade and freedom of movement etc. A protocal for Northern Ireland was appended to the Withdrawal Agreement so why not one for Jersey?
Posted by Bruce Willing on
Guernsey seems to have reached an agreement with French fishermen; why not Jersey?
Posted by Raphaël Fremond on
Et bien... Pourquoi ne prolonger le traité de la baie de Granville, il avait le mérite d'être équitable
Posted by Robert Gabriel on
The Jersey electorate weren’t party to the UK leaving the EU. However, here we are now having to try to sort out some of the problems that decision has caused. The sooner Jersey becomes independent the better!
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?