St Sampson’s and Vale douzaines have fired shots at the Development and Planning Authority – with both highlighting concerns about the pressure being put on the infrastructure in the north of the island.
St Sampson’s Douzaine has gone so far as to claim that the proposed changes to the Island Development Plan put the north of Guernsey at a real risk of infrastructure failure.
That has been echoed by the Vale Douzaine which has cited concerns about the pressure on infrastructure if more than 1000 new homes are built in close proximity across the two parishes.

Both parishes have repeatedly raised concerns over the level of proposed development in the north of the island, with St Sampson’s officials now saying those concerns have been ignored in the latest review of the IDP.
As well as highlighting traffic management concerns, St Sampson’s Douzaine warns building an estimated 1,400 new homes in the parish and the Vale could have a serious “consequential impact” on existing infrastructure including roads, foul and surface water drainage, and water and electricity supplies.
“This broader issue is manifestly more serious than concerns being raised about individual sites,” said the Douzaine.
In its own response to the IDP review, the Vale Douzaine warned “the combined impact on roads, drainage, local services and employment land needs to be properly assessed before changes to the Island Development Plan are approved”.
Vale Constable Richard Leale has told deputies that the Douzaine “fully recognises the urgent need for more affordable housing in the island. However, members believe that the requirement could be met more effectively by identifying a wider range of sites across the island, particularly locations where development could proceed more quickly, with less pressure on existing infrastructure, more open space and less additional traffic congestion”.

Residential developments have been focused on the north of the island in recent years, with a number of sites already approved for new housing.
The latest review of the IDP – due to be debated by the States next week – has allocated 31.9% of new housing stock in St Sampson’s and 25.4% in Vale, meaning a total of 57.3% of all new housing stock would be built in the north of the island.
This compares with none proposed to be built in St Saviour’s, Torteval, or St Andrew’s.
1.5% of all new housing is planned for St Peter’s, 6.6% in Forest, 7.6% in Castel, 10.3% in St Martin’s, and 16.7% in St Peter Port.
The Vale Douzaine said it is concerned that simplifying some of the planning requirements to speed up housing delivery will cause problems in the long run and it wants greater transparency about how deliverable proposed housing sites in the parish and nearby really are.

Shining the spotlight on some specific sites, St Sampson’s Douzaine has outright opposed some and asked the States to carry out “a comprehensive assessment of traffic impacts arising from all development sites in the north of the island to help determine the priority and extent to which large scale housing developments can be allowed to proceed”.
St Sampson’s Douzaine has also backed the creation of a new ‘Local Centre’ at Vazon – which is being opposed by residents already living there.
The parish also supports plans to create six ‘Priority Affordable Housing sites’ in other parishes, while backing plans to build at the old Fletcher’s Fresias site on Route Carre in St Sampson’s – but not at Sandy Hook.
The Douzaine has urged the States to “maximise existing and future housing development opportunities away from the north to distribute the provision of much needed housing more equitably across the island”.
Accepting that some developments have to go ahead in the north of the island, it reiterates that the allocation of housing provision remains “substantially higher” in St Sampson’s and the Vale than elsewhere.
“The above propositions, along with several other proposed plan amendments recommended by the DPA, will further increase pressure on infrastructure in the north of the island and the risk of infrastructure failure remains a very real issue,” warns the St Sampson’s Douzaine.
On behalf of the Vale Douzaine, Mr Leale said the parish is not seeking to prevent much-needed housing development, but wants to ensure that “the consequences for the Vale and neighbouring parishes were properly understood before binding decisions were made”.
Vale Douzaine is also calling for a comprehensive assessment of the cumulative impact of the proposed developments, covering housing numbers, traffic, pedestrian safety, drainage, utilities, schools, community facilities and the loss and replacement of employment land before any further decisions are made.
