A Jersey doctor declared bankrupt nearly a decade ago has lost a court challenge to force the island’s chief enforcement officer to fund her legal fight in England.

In a judgment delivered by the Royal Court, Dr Gail Cochrane failed to overturn a decision by the Viscount – the official responsible for administering bankrupt estates in Jersey – who refused to release £19,500 from her assets to pay for legal advice.

An “overwhelmingly complex” legal saga

The case forms part of a long-running and, in the court’s words, “overwhelmingly complex” legal saga stemming from the collapse of litigation funding arrangements tied to a company linked to Dr Cochrane and her former husband who has previously been convicted of fraud charges.

Dr Gail Cochrane was officially deemed ‘en désastre’ – Jersey’s equivalent of bankruptcy – in 2016, alongside the company Orb, for which she was believed to be the sole shareholder at the time, with a number of creditors claiming sums that racked up collectively to over £1bn.

In 2017, however, she claimed that she owned very little and was not able to pay the creditors. 

This was despite having previously told the Royal Court she was a “very wealthy woman, with holdings in dozens of companies worldwide” and an array of properties around the world.

She is now trying to overturn that bankruptcy, arguing the funding arrangement may be unenforceable under English law following a landmark UK Supreme Court ruling on litigation funding agreements.

But the latest dispute did not concern the merits of that claim.

Instead, Dr Cochrane asked the Viscount to release funds from her bankrupt estate so she could obtain legal advice from English counsel ahead of proceedings in the High Court.

Her lawyers said she needed the money because the litigation involved complex technical issues and she was otherwise acting alone.

The request sought £19,500 for an opinion from English counsel.

“It is not the Viscount’s responsibility to provide funding… for significant legal fees”

The Viscount declined, arguing that the law allowing him to release money from a bankrupt person’s assets is intended for living expenses – not major legal bills.

The court heard that the bankrupt estate currently held around £159,000 in realised assets, while claims against it totalled more than £319 million.

In a letter refusing the request, the Viscount wrote to Dr Cochrane’s lawyers: “It is not the Viscount’s responsibility to provide funding to your client for significant legal fees, and there is no precedent for the Viscount to do so.”

They added that the relevant legal provision allows the Viscount to release funds only for “the support of the debtor and his or her dependants”, which was not considered to include large legal costs.

The Viscount also questioned whether Dr Cochrane might have other sources of funding, citing earlier litigation that suggested assistance from third parties.

“Hamstrung”?

Dr Cochrane’s legal team argued the refusal was unfair and irrational.

They said the Viscount had relied on historical suspicions about her finances rather than focusing on the current request.

Without funding, they argued, she was effectively prevented from properly defending herself in the English proceedings.

Her advocate told the court the decision had left her “hamstrung in her opposition” to the claim brought in London.

They also argued the Viscount’s approach amounted to a blanket policy against funding legal costs – something they said the law did not permit.

The Royal Court rejected the challenge.

Judges said their role was limited to reviewing whether the Viscount had acted unlawfully or irrationally – a high threshold.

They concluded he had properly exercised his discretion.

The court emphasised that the power to release funds exists primarily to support basic living needs.

Dr Cochrane’s request was fundamentally different, it said: “This request is very far from requiring support for a debtor and/or dependants.”

Instead, the court said, she was effectively asking to use assets held for creditors to try to end the bankruptcy itself.

While acknowledging the consequences for her, the judges said the Viscount had been entitled to refuse.

“We appreciate that the Viscount’s conclusion leaves the Representor without access to legal advice, but the Viscount was well aware of that as an outcome.”

They also rejected claims that the Viscount had a conflict of interest or had failed to properly consider the request.

For now, the bankruptcy remains in place, and the Viscount will continue administering Dr Cochrane’s estate while related proceedings continue in England.

READ MORE…

Doctor who allegedly owes £1.25 billion says she has no money (2017)

Doctor potentially owing over £300m has bankruptcy order extended (2021)

Doctor in landmark case applies to no longer be declared ‘bankrupt’ (2024)

Court clears way for further seizure of assets linked to Jersey fraudster Dr Gerald Smith (2025)