Fire Service improvements are being deferred because of resource constraints – despite warnings of “extreme” risks linked to safety, training and the monitoring of operational standards.
A government response to a report by a report by the Comptroller and Auditor General revealed that monitoring of compliance with national firefighting guidance depends on securing additional resources, while a fuller set of performance measures will follow work planned for 2027.
A review of training needs and budgets will also be undertaken according to the resources available.
The response, presented to the States by the Public Accounts Committee, follows the C&AG’s March report on the States of Jersey Fire and Rescue Service. It found that the government has continued to accept major risks to the island’s emergency response capability while failing to put in place a clear strategy to address them.
The audit also found the service is currently operating with a large number of “extreme risks”, many of which cannot be addressed in the short term under existing arrangements.
The response acknowledged an existing “extreme” risk relating to the service’s inability to demonstrate its adoption or adaptation of National Operational Guidance, which guides operational firefighting practice.
Although progress is being made, the response identifies “a lack of capacity to properly track and monitor progress”.
The recommendation to strengthen that monitoring is accepted but deferred because comprehensive tracking depends on identifying additional resources. The improvement plan sets a target of the third quarter of 2027, subject to approval of a business case and funding.
Training carries another “extreme” risk rating. The response warns that “inadequate or poorly targeted training could lead to significant operational, safety or statutory consequences”.
A review intended to ensure that training meets needs and makes best use of its budget is only partially agreed, with delivery dependent on the approach to implementing national guidance and the resources available.
Meanwhile, fuller measures of the service’s performance are deferred into 2027. The response warns that gaps in monitoring could allow weaknesses to go unnoticed, potentially leading to failures to meet legal duties and long-term harm.
However, it stresses that this “extreme” rating reflects “reduced assurance and visibility over performance and risk rather than evidence of service failure”. An initial set of performance indicators has already been released.
Critical IT projects present a further concern, with the response warning that delays or gaps could impact the service’s ability to manage operational risks and maintain safe working systems.
A further review will examine work outside normal fire-service responsibilities, including whether a formal agreement with Health and Care Jersey is needed to clarify duties, service standards and value for money.
The response warns that such work can divert resources from core firefighting duties, reducing capacity for training, fire prevention and emergency readiness. The review is also marked as deferred, with work to be prioritised according to existing resource constraints.
Justice and Home Affairs said the recommendations were broadly accepted and aligned closely with improvements already underway.
“Where recommendations cannot be implemented immediately, the associated risks are acknowledged and will continue to be actively managed through established risk registers and governance arrangements,” it said.
The Public Accounts Committee will review the response and consider publishing further comments.
