Thursday 28 October 2021
Select a region

Challenge to “legitimacy” of covid Ministerial group

Challenge to “legitimacy” of covid Ministerial group

Friday 25 June 2021

Challenge to “legitimacy” of covid Ministerial group

Scrutineers are challenging the recent decisions and “legitimacy” of the small group of Ministers that have had the final say on restrictions on islanders’ lives since the beginning of the health crisis, questioning whether they should be able to continue any longer.

In a critical letter on behalf of panels tasked with reviewing covid strategy, Senator Kristina Moore calls out “inconsistency” in policy decisions taken by ‘Competent Authority Ministers’ (CAM) and urges the Chief Minister to act “immediately, decisively and unambiguously."

CAM is made up of the Chief Minister, and Ministers of Health, Home Affairs, Economic Development, External Relations and Infrastructure. The Treasury and Education Ministers are not statutory members, but were invited when the importance of their portfolios in relation to covid-19 measures became apparent. 


Pictured: Senator Kristina Moore was writing in her capacity as Chair of the Scrutiny Liaison Committee, which brings together the chairs of all five Scrutiny Panels.

Decisions in the firing line included the approach to travel, mask-wearing, events sector support and gatherings guidance, which saw a gala dinner with the British and Irish Lions able to go ahead but other, smaller events called off.

“Large government backed corporate events have been authorised but private gatherings for numbers over 20 (excluding weddings and funerals) even if professionally organised have continued to remain restricted, until 5th July 2021 at the earliest,” she noted.

Senator Moore also highlighted inadequacies in the financial support for the events industry and other sectors “significantly affected by policy”.

Jersey Kitchen owner Tony Sargeant recently wrote a candid column on both aspects, criticising the Government for “hypocrisy”, “backtracking” and “double standards”.


Pictured: "How can it be ok to allow a wedding for an unlimited number of guests in a field but only have a maximum of 20 guests if it’s for a private party?" Mr Sargeant questioned.

“How can it possibly be acceptable to allow a corporate dinner for 500 people to go ahead this week - indoors and with alcohol flowing, whilst at the same time a birthday party for 21 guests in a garden is not permitted? Can someone explain the rationale to me please because I sure as hell can’t understand it,” he wrote.

“The Lions' dinner for 500 guests was never, ever, ever not going to be allowed to go ahead. Why? Because it was the political will to make sure it went ahead by whatever means necessary which obviously includes bending or ‘re-interpreting’ the rules to suit - ha!”

In her letter, Senator Moore also highlighted how changes to travel rules have been made, in “somewhat quick succession” in recent weeks, causing confusion for travellers. 

Last week, Ministers announced their decision to apply ‘49 additional emergency brakes’ for UK regions ahead of the whole of England turning red in the traffic light system from 29 June. At the same time, they said travellers who are fully vaccinated in the Common Travel Area can avoid full quarantine, before then this week extending that to those double-jabbed with an authorised vaccine anywhere in the world.


Pictured: Scrutineers raised questions over the rapidly changing travel policy, which they said had caused confusion.

Senator Moore also noted how the difference between guidelines and legal restrictions, such as the wearing of masks and physical distancing, was similarly causing confusion.

In the second part of her letter, Senator Moore wrote about her Committee’s “increasing concern” about the inefficiency of the “number, nature and respective meeting schedules of overlapping decision-making or influencing bodies” – these being the Competent Authority Ministers (CAM), the Emergencies Council and the full Council of Ministers.

She said the Committee had doubts over the value of CAM, whose legitimacy and status she said had been questioned several times.

Senator Moore added that Scrutineers "seriously question the merits of its continued existence", noting that CAM were "often" making decisions "at the expense of more appropriate deliberations by the full Council of Ministers."

"...Should it continue, the Committee concludes that greater clarity over the role of CAM is required,” she wrote.

Turning to scientific advisory panel STAC, which makes recommendations to CAM before they make the final decision, she raised the “scale” of the influence of non-health experts joining the group.

She also noted how the minutes of the Scientific and Technical Advisory Cell (STAC) are almost three months behind – the latest ones go back to 29 March.

States Assembly.jpeg

Pictured: Senator Moore urged Ministers to share more information with the States Assembly.

Meanwhile, despite requests from Express, the Government has so far refused to disclose the minutes from the CAM’s meetings, arguing it would not be in the public interest as it would compromise their “safe space” in which to make decisions and “reveal potential disagreements on details of policy.” Express has appealed this decision.

Senator Moore said that various Scrutiny Panels had been reported that they had been briefed on policy changes “minutes before or after” media announcements, which she said was “not inducive to passing comment to aid any decision-making process”.

She suggested the information considered by CAM should be shared with Scrutiny members and the whole States Assembly when decisions are communicated directly after a meeting “to avoid speculation and aid in clarity when reviewing the changes being made”.

“The Committee would also highlight its concern about the move away from seeking the approval of the Assembly, which took place earlier on in the pandemic through propositions such as [the Safer Travel Policy].

"The Committee would suggest that consideration of alternative, informed views, will not hinder, but aid in the work of CAM. Failing to do so further risks undermining the decision process of the States Assembly and wider Ministerial oversight of the Government of Jersey. We would therefore suggest that members of the Council of Ministers and Scrutiny should pass comment on any potential changes, even in draft form.” 

READ: Click to read the letter in full...


Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Private Individual on
Once again Senator Moore is doing the job in scrutiny that our council of ministers should be doing.

It is an insult to Jersey residents that the Lions who are supported by a small minority of people were allowed to come to Jersey (paid for with taxpayer's money 175k ) and allowed to have entertainment with 500 people present whilst genuine businesses were not allowed to open.

The government is complicit in this by allowing it to happen, this is not supporting local business, it is purely a "Jolly" for the boys using money that should have been used to support local business.
Posted by Steven Simon on
Bunch of incompetent personal at the helm, making it work for themselves. Let’s just hope they don’t get re-elected. Fingers crossed. That is if they even stand again. It’s unbelievable. Let’s hope the public remember what has gone on under JLF government when elections come around.
Posted by Donal Dolo on
these clowns have done more damage than covid
Posted by Jon Jon on
Moore now looking ahead to next years elections by being vocal over this! but have to admit this current bunch are well out their depth and hopefully next years election will have them rejected by public.
Posted by Paul Troalic on
Once again Senator Kristina Moore has caught the COM out. They thought they would get away with this event because of the (apparent huge) interest in rugby.
Sorry it is a minority sport and the only reason the COM allowed this event was to pander to the rich. Again.
Well done Senator Moore.
Too many mixed messages are and have been sent it to the public. At some point they will say enough is enough and this horrible lot of politicians will be gone.
Cannot wait!
Posted by Keith Marsh on
Everyone knows I'm no fan of this Government ~ but I feel Sen. Moore is playing the Political game.
Posted by Julie Littlemore on
Someone needs to speak out as there have been 3 government events that I know of in the past week Dan numbers are rising rapidly- I wonder why ? It is. It fair to businesses involved in the events sector, and most definitely not to the general public, when there is one rule for us and one rule for the government. Come on guys do you really think residents are walking around with their eyes closed ?
Posted by Martin on
FOUR out of the five pictured above should be ousted with alacrity AND gusto!
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?