Lifeboat dispute: RNLI promises "fair and comprehensive" review

Thursday 20 April 2017

The RNLI has confirmed their former St Helier Coxswain, who was controversially “stood down” following an alleged breach of the charity’s Volunteer Code of Conduct, has formally appealed the decision. They have also urged Islanders to stop speculating on what really lies behind the decision, and to stop publicly referring to the people involved.

The RNLI told Express that Coxswain of over 25 years Andy Hibbs (44), whose dismissal has led to a public uproar and the resignation of his 25-person crew, will now go through a, “...fair and comprehensive internal review into the challenge and the processes that led to the decision".

“This will be undertaken by objective RNLI staff who were not involved in the decision to stand down the volunteer or any related matters,” a spokesperson for RNLI South said. 

The reasons behind the original decision have never been made clear, however, leaving a large question mark hanging over what the dispute is actually about.

Speculation peaked in the States Assembly this week, with St Helier Deputy Russell Labey putting forward a theory as to what led to the dispute, which was later refuted by Mike Jackson, the local spokesperson for the crew. 

In a statement today, the RNLI called for an end to the speculation, while their disciplinary process continued, and urged Islanders to stop publicly referring to those involved: 

“Whilst this is taking place we urge people to respect the confidential process and those involved by not speculating any further or referring to individual people or groups.”

Earlier this week, Mr Jackson confirmed that a “positive” meeting had taken place between the crew and the Chief Minister and Assistant Minister Senator Paul Routier, who had previously appealed for the team to take up their positions again.

Pictured: Senator Paul Routier addresses the crowds at the public show of support earlier this month.

Mr Jackson added: “We had a productive meeting… Certain discussions need to be had, and the Chief Minister and Senator Paul Routier have been very supportive, so we look forward to further developments and hope the whole matter is brought to a conclusion as soon as possible…

“We’re not there yet, but we’re moving forward.”