Monday 02 October 2023
Select a region

Campaigners: "Common sense has prevailed" on hospital – but time to come clean on cost


Friday 02 June 2023

Campaigners: "Common sense has prevailed" on hospital – but time to come clean on cost

Friday 02 June 2023

Campaigners against the previous £800m Overdale hospital project have tentatively welcomed the "common sense" approach of the new Government – but hope Ministers will soon "come clean" on cost.

Chief Minister Kristina Moore's Government confirmed on Wednesday that their preferred way forward was to build a new inpatients facility at Overdale and an outpatients’ facility in town, with a 'Health Village' in St. Saviour.

Advocate Olaf Blakeley, who was a spokesperson for residents of the Westmount area, proposed a ‘requête’ in February 2021 which rejected the then-Government’s offer to buy parish land around the People’s Park and Westmount Road.

Although the Government later issued compulsory purchase orders to acquire the parish land, they were never enacted.

This week, the new Government which supports building a smaller hospital at Overdale than the previous campus proposal, and constructing a new ‘ambulatory’ unit in Kensington Place and Gloucester Street.

Last plan "short-sighted"

Responding to the Government's announcement this week, Advocate Blakeley said: “For my part, I am very pleased that at last common sense has prevailed and a sensible solution has been found.

“In my opinion, it was extremely short-sighted of the previous Government to continue to believe in and press for the so-called ‘health campus’ at Overdale once the requête was served which stopped the Parish of St. Helier negotiating the sale of land. 

“The requête and the protests by interested people against the hospital project succeeded in derailing the development for long enough for the whole matter to be considered afresh by a new elected States.”

Islanders "should not be ‘gun-to-the-head-forced’ into accepting a wholly harebrained scheme"

He added: “I have always supported the building of a new hospital. The island needs a new hospital. It is needed for the public of the Island. It is also needed by those who work so hard in the health industry as they deserve a building which is modern and which makes their difficult jobs easier. 

“However, I have also always said that, no matter how desperate the need for a hospital, the public should not be ‘gun-to-the-head-forced’ into accepting a wholly harebrained scheme either because time has run out or the will to find a better solution has been gnawed at and eventually destroyed."


Pictured: Advocate Blakeley joined other Westmount residents in opposing the felling of trees around the People's Park.

He continued: “Again, in my opinion, it should have been obvious to all that building such an important building on the top of a hill to which access is made via winding narrow roads was misguided. 

“The idea of developing the town site is a sensible one and should have been done a long time ago. While I accept previous applications for planning permissions were rejected, that should not have been a barrier to development because the States could have done what they attempted to do with the Overdale site: change the Island Plan so that planning applications would be compliant. 

“I know this saga has been going on for an incredibly long time and that much of the public are probably fed up but ultimately, I think we are now almost there. It is a great shame that so much money has been spent and wasted but better that than giving up and settling for an inappropriate development in an inappropriate location.”

"Come clean" on cost

Meanwhile, Peter Funk, from the Friends of Our New Hospital group, which campaigned against the Overdale 'health campus' plan, said he was "quietly encouraged" by the latest plans, but added that " there is still a hell of a lot more information to be provided".

"Spreading the facilities across several sites is a good idea, probably the only idea at this stage, and is much more manageable, but there’s no clarity about how much it will cost," he explained.

Former political leader of the Our Hospital project, Deputy Lyndon Farnham, said he is willing to support the new multi-site plan on condition that the Government “comes clean” about its cost.

He argues that ministers need to prove their assertions that the new preferred option is more affordable than the project he led, which in August 2021 was estimated to cost £804.5m.

If they cannot, they need to admit that it will cost more, he says, adding that he may well still back it.

However, supporters say that rising inflation means that direct comparisons between the two schemes are impossible to make.


WATCH: Viral victory for lawyer’s hospital highway ‘fact check’

Lawyer barred from representing parishioners in hospital highway vote

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Martin on
Dear Bailiwick Express!

PLEASE do not use the words "Common Sense"& "Government" in the SAME sentence as it totally confuses the public!
Posted by IanSmith97 on
Who would those “campaigners” be? Would they be the armchair experts ie not the doctors, nurses and healthcare staff who said the original one site plan was the way to go? Would they be those who got politicians to ignore the actual experts who actually treat sick people and work in health and know what’s required? Would they be the know-it-alls who know precious little about actual healthcare? Yes? That’s the way to go then isn’t it? We will pay dearly for this farce over and above £800 million for the one site hospital and the £130 million already wasted and not a sod of earth turned. Shameful incompetence.
Posted by Jim Les Q on
I hope the two people quoted in this article will be equally as vocal when they realise the true cost of what they, and a few other interested neighbours, have genuinely cost our island. And I am not talking about just costs. Health care workers are leaving in their droves due to the condition they work in at our hospital, and there are barely any developers left a capable of delivering this new ridiculous scheme which will see so much unnecessary duplication - and those that are left won’t touch it with a barge pole. I hope you are genuinely proud of your work Mr Blakey and Mr Funk. Deep down, I suspect you are feeling rather guilty!
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?