Sunday 25 February 2024
Select a region

"Transparency" concerns as Ministers fail to release covid minutes

Thursday 23 December 2021

"Transparency" concerns as Ministers fail to release covid minutes

Thursday 23 December 2021

Ministers are still yet to release minutes of their covid meetings for scrutiny - despite pledging to do so nearly two months ago.

Express has been campaigning for many months for minutes of meetings of the Competent Authority Ministers’ (CAM) – those who, legally, had the final say on all covid restrictions - to be released.

It came after STAC minutes exposed concerns by medics that Ministers had deviated from their strong advice in areas such as travel.

Following challenges under the Freedom of Information Law, the Government decided that they should remain locked away, arguing that Ministers needed a ‘safe space’ for their discussions

However, they partially relented on 3 November, when it was agreed by the States Assembly that they would be shared, in confidence, with politicians officially tasked with reviewing the Government’s response to the pandemic.


Pictured: CAM - External Relations Minister Ian Gorst, Economic Development Minister Lyndon Farnham, Chief Minister John Le Fondré, Health Minister Richard Renouf, Infrastructure Minister Kevin Lewis and Home Affairs Minister Gregory Guida.

The proposition was approved with 37 votes in favour and five votes against. Those who opposed releasing the minutes were Home Affairs Minister Gregory Guida, Treasury Minister Susie Pinel and her Assistant Minister Lindsay Ash, Assistant Chief Minister Rowland Huelin, and Trinity Constable Philip Le Sueur.

Since then, Scrutineers say they have made “multiple enquiries regarding the whereabouts of the CAM meeting minutes and when Scrutiny can expect to receive them” to no avail.

Expressing concern about the lack of clarity, Chief Scrutineer, President of the Liaison Committee Senator Kristina Moore, explained: “Transparency in Government decision-making is essential, particularly when such decisions impact the entire island.

”The failure to share CAM minutes with Scrutiny, even after this request was approved by the States Assembly, hinders Scrutiny from carrying out its core function as a critical friend which holds the Government to account.

“We recommend that this is rectified immediately so that Scrutiny is able to provide confidence to the Assembly and the public when it comes to emergency decision-making in response to covid-19.”


FOCUS: Ministers relent in battle to have pandemic meeting minutes scrutinised

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by nigel pearce on
It seems that our government doesn’t do ‘freedom of information’ unless it suits them.
Posted by Martin on
Posted by Keith Marsh on
Has CAM received written confirmation of security from those politicians officially tasked with reviewing the Government’s response to the pandemic ? This is strictly confidential information ~ and hence subject to leaks.
The CAM has to be certain that their of the record discussions stay "confidential"
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?