WATCH: Condor crew member guilty of endangering lives in L’Ecume II trial

A Condor crewman has been found guilty of endangering lives over the fatal trawler collision which killed three fishermen – but jurors could not reach a verdict on manslaughter charges.

Lewis Carr (30) was today found guilty of conduct endangering individuals, ships or structures under the Shipping (Jersey) Law 2002 after 19 hours and 18 minutes of deliberation.

The guilty verdict was unanimous, and Carr was remanded in custody.

18 hours of deliberation

It comes after the jury yesterday cleared his co-accused Artur Sevash-Zade (35) of manslaughter after 18 hours and five minutes of deliberation.

Mr Sevash-Zade was discharged from court proceedings this morning after the jury failed to reach a majority verdict on the lesser alternative charge.

L’Ecume II crew members Michael Michieli, Larry Simyunn and Jervis Baligat all died when the Commodore Goodwill collided with their trawler in December 2022.

Carr and Mr Sevash-Zade were the only people on the bridge of the Condor ship at the time of the crash, which prompted a major search-and-rescue operation involving a number of agencies and members of the fishing community.

The bodies of Mr Simyunn and Mr Baligat were recovered near the wreck. Mr Michieli’s body was recovered some months later in a room below deck.

The trial has lasted three weeks, and jurors have been deliberating since Tuesday morning.

Commissioner Sir John Saunders was presiding.

“Our thoughts remain with the families”

Following the verdict, Senior Investigating Officer Andy Shearwood said: “First and foremost, our thoughts remain with the families of Michael, Jervis and Larry. They have suffered an immeasurable loss and have shown extraordinary dignity throughout this process.

“This was one of the most complex investigations the States of Jersey Police has ever undertaken. Under ‘Operation Nectar’ and alongside the Law Officers’ Department, the States of Jersey Police worked tirelessly to establish the facts and bring this matter before the court.

While today’s verdict will not undo the events of that morning, we hope the conclusion of this trial provides some measure of closure for families and allows our community to begin moving forward

Senior Investigating Officer Andy Shearwood

“While today’s verdict will not undo the events of that morning, we hope the conclusion of this trial provides some measure of closure for families and allows our community to begin moving forward.”

More than 1,000 exhibits examined

States of Jersey police chief Officer Robin Smith added: “My first thoughts are with the bereaved families and friends who have exhibited remarkable dignity despite their loss.

“Almost three years ago, the States of Jersey Police began, at that time, its largest and most complex investigation in its history.

“I am very proud of the officers and staff who have worked so hard in contributing to today’s verdict. From a standing start they have immersed themselves in complex maritime law, technology, policy and procedures.

“They have worked tirelessly taking hundreds of statements, interviewing over 150 witnesses, examining around 800 documents and seizing over 1,000 exhibits.”

He continued: “The dedication of our team of Family Liaison Officers over the last few years often goes unnoticed but their contribution deserves recognition.

“Today’s outcome is a testament to their professionalism, commitment and resilience.”

Mr Smith added: “Recent history shows that when faced with tragedy islanders, agencies and organisations come together. Very complex cases like this cannot be delivered without an island-wide effort.

“The expertise of the Law Officers’ Department has been invaluable, and I am grateful for the way we have worked hand in glove since the start of this investigation.

“I’d also like to acknowledge Andy Shearwood’s (Senior Investigating Officer) leadership throughout the investigation and Crown Advocate Matthew Maletroit who has worked very hard over a number of months and especially the last three weeks.

“I am grateful too for the unwavering support and backing from the Government of Jersey, the Jersey Police Authority not to mention the patience of all interested parties.”

Follow Express for updates…