Public financial support of the colleges will continue at current levels after Education’s bid to scrap the funding floundered badly.

An amendment by Deputy Gavin St Pier ensured the spend to support Elizabeth, Blanchelande and The Ladies’ College, which is around £3m. annually, is linked to inflation and will reduce should pupil numbers fall.

The deal is locked in so that a five year notice period is needed to change it.

In what was a tough debate for Education that got tetchy, their report was also amended to ensure that partnership working with the High Schools will primarily happen organically at staff level, not encumbered by politicians or the committee’s staff. 

A statement from the independent colleges said that they were relieved that the government funding has been secured following this week’s debate.

“We are grateful to deputies for seeing the valuable role the Colleges play in the Bailiwick’s educational landscape, island-wide community and economy,” it said.

“We would also like to acknowledge the high level of political, parent and public engagement in this important debate and the significant support we have received from the business sector and other stakeholders.

“The colleges are also very pleased to have the opportunity to work with other schools and their leaders at a grass roots level and are excited by what might be achieved.” 

Deputies rejected options which included eliminating the inflation link to save money and blocked debate on introducing a bursary scheme which would have had some element of selection linked to it.

Pictured: Deputy Andrea Dudley-Owen

Education, Sport & Culture President Andrea Dudley-Owen was in no doubt that the committee will have to come back next term seeking funding for “investment in education across the board because it is absolutely vital”.

Her committee had envisaged using the money from the College funding for initiatives in the High Schools.

“We cannot save our way to success,” she said.

“We have to invest our way to success. We have to invest in the pipeline of young people coming through. We have to invest in supporting our families, to have more children, to give them the confidence that this is the island that they want to stay in and also to make it attractive for people who come and work here, and we’re simply not doing enough at the moment.”

Facing some criticism of what was happening in the States sector, she insisted there was a picture of “an ever improving education sector”.

“Yes, there’s still pockets where we need more resourcing and more support, but it is a generally positive trajectory, and that is proved by our education strategy report that we released earlier in the year.

“I’m really thrilled to hear Deputy Ferbrache and Deputy Leadbetter singing the praises of the State sector and others as well and I wish that that would be the resounding view of some of our media as well, because actually we really do ourselves down and Guernsey PLC with with commentary which is less than positive. 

“Of course, you’re never going to get everything right. But where we’re dealing with 9,000 children and young people. We’ve got 1,000 staff members, plus those in the colleges, there’s always going to be something that isn’t quite right. We’re dealing with humans here. We’re complex individuals. But then there definitely needs to be a resounding support for the the education system going forward.”

She admitted to finding it difficult to support the new funding package, but said she would so as not to leave the colleges with no funding.

“I go into this support with my eyes absolutely wide open, and I ask members who are supporting it to acknowledge the policy conflict that we are baking in here. And I am only supporting this because it is clear that the financial viability of our colleges is in jeopardy otherwise. 

“But we are continuing to support a selective system, and my remedy to that is for the colleges to remove their selection process, and I hope that that will be considered by the colleges, because that is the fairest way forward.”

Pictured: Deputy Heidi Soulsby

Deputy Heidi Soulsby, who is on the Ladies’ College board of governors, led the amendment on partnership working.

In the run up to the debate, the Colleges’ had gone public with frustration that this area had broken down in recent years and proposals they had put forward ignored by ESC.

Deputy Soulsby insisted her amendment was not perspective.

“It’s about encouraging and supporting and trying to make things happen now,” she said.

She said that the amendment arose because of the colleges’ trust in what  had been done had broken down.

“They feel absolutely there needs to be an amendment so they know that they can have that real partnership working.”

At every stage, the colleges have been prevented from talking to their colleagues in the State sector, she said, giving the example of how States staff were blocked from taking part in AI training they had put on.

Deputy Dudley-Owen denied that was the case and insisted she was very keen to foster strong relationships between the States and College sectors.

To see how they voted on Deputy St Pier’s amendment to continue funding the colleges click HERE.