Monday 08 August 2022
Select a region

WATCH: Fish war narrows to 13 French 'replacement vessels'

WATCH: Fish war narrows to 13 French 'replacement vessels'

Wednesday 03 November 2021

WATCH: Fish war narrows to 13 French 'replacement vessels'

Wednesday 03 November 2021

The fishing row between Jersey and France appears to have narrowed to 13 boats and whether their owners acquired the right to work in local waters in vessels that have since been replaced.

Last night, French Fisheries Minister Annick Girardin told the country’s National Assembly: “We also want Jersey to accept to reconsider the 13 vessels that France wishes to see obtain licences very quickly.”

She added: “And of course, we also want a precise calendar to tackle all the other topics, such as temporary licences and technical measures.”

On Monday, France delayed taking retaliatory measures against the UK and Jersey – due to come in yesterday – until UK Brexit Minister Lord Frost and France’s Europe Minister Clément Beaune meet on Thursday.

However, Mme Girdard told the Assembly that she wanted to UK response, by last night, on a document detailing the conditions for obtaining licences for the 14 vessels in the 6-12 nautical mile zone.

“We want to have a conclusive meeting organised tomorrow [Wednesday], presided by the European Commission – that’s its role – on replacement vessels,” she said.

It is not yet known if she received a UK response by last night.

fishing boats protest.jpg

Pictured: French fishermen protested outside the Harbour in May.

External Relations Minister Ian Gorst confirmed to the Guardian yesterday that the issue of replacement vessels was a sticking point.

However, he added that he hoped for an early resolution.

“There are some issues around replacement vessels that we can sort out earlier than we might have envisaged, that is for both us and the UK,” he said.

“I think that would be quite a good way to move things forward and allow more time. Of the vessels that the EU is asking us to reconsider, at least a handful, about five or six, are replacement vessels …

“The French have taken the view that it is better to try to deal with the individual vessels than trigger countermeasures whereby everybody will become entrenched.”

Giving a French regional perspective, Marc Delahaye, Director of Normandy’s fishing committee, told La Presse de la Manche: “Since the last announcement from Jersey last week, there has been little change.

“For boats less than 12 metres, which required the most work from our regional committee, 48 Norman boats, out of 79 licences, have permanent access, 20 remain in the provisional ‘orange’ category, out of a total of 49, and eight had to stop fishing on Sunday because they had no licence.

“The British only seem to want to accept ships that are identical in all respects, while new or recent boats can only present technical developments.

“But some shipowners have acquired rights through prior fishing experience with their old vessel. And there are also young people who have just moved in, and they don't have any.

“With Jersey, this is the case with about 15 boats. You would expect that Jersey will line up with London’s position.”

Pictured: UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson briefly addresses the fishing issue at the end of a press conference in Glasgow on Tuesday.

Meanwhile, UK Prime Minister yesterday downplayed the fishing dispute when asked about it at a COP26 press conference in Glasgow, which French President Emmanuel Macron reportedly left prematurely yesterday.

Mr Johnson told a reporter: “On our relations with France, I really renew what I’ve said before: we are working very closely with our French friends and partners on the things that matter most to the people of the world, which is tackling climate change and reducing CO2.

“By comparison with that hugely important issue, the ones you mention are vanishingly unimportant, but since you ask whether the UK has changed its position on the fishing issue, the answer is no.”

A European Commission spokesperson told Express last night: "Talks continued today. It is positive and reassuring to see contacts aiming at a solution. Technical meetings to resume on Wednesday."

Yesterday, Chief Minister John Le Fondré told Times Radio that he found it “difficult to understand” why many French boats hadn’t been able to produce the required information because the previous Bay of Granville agreement “laid down requirements for them to record their fishing records.” 

During May’s flare-up in fishing licence tensions, which resulted in scores of French fishers storming St. Helier harbour, Home Affairs Minister Deputy Gregory Guida said that the paperwork sent to Jersey up to that point was full of “horreurs”, including missing and duplicated documents.

Both Ministers confirmed the island had resorted to buying commercial information to plug gaps in the information provided by France.


Jersey forced to buy data to plug French fishing gaps

WATCH: Macron puts Jersey fish wars on ice

WATCH: Calls for Jersey to retaliate as G20 talks fail to calm fishing row

ANALYSIS: Lost in translation? Or wilfully deaf ears?

Condor moves French sailings to blacklisted port over winter

View from France: Fishers "are happy and just want to get on with fishing"

WATCH: Jersey grants 75% of fishing licences requested by France

WATCH: Jersey blindsided by "disproportionate" French fishing threats

Jersey awaits French reaction after fishing licence decision

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Martin on
GIRARDIN WANTS Jersey to ACCEPT & RECONSIDER the 13 fishing licences & VERY quickly!

I was going to cover EACH of GIRARDIN,s WANTS on this article and quickly realised I had set myself a massive task regarding the plethora of her WANTS!

May have been needy as a child? < - delete if necessary.

WHAT Annick wants is NOT down to ANNICK as it IS Jersey Waters and she should be less bullish & try a bit of reasonable action rather than antagonistic behaviour!

Maybe Jersey/Gsy/Uk should bombard WANTER Girardin with a "raft" of wishes which are in no way a legal or moral entitlement!

This should send her into a frenzy for some time & we can all get back to fishing our respective waters?
Posted by Donald Grigg on
I wonder if once a licence is awarded whether the owner can then sell that licence to another boat. If so it would explain the number of small boat requests
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?