Friday 24 March 2023
Select a region

FOCUS: Strive expansion and protection for Ouaisné supported in Island Plan

FOCUS: Strive expansion and protection for Ouaisné supported in Island Plan

Monday 14 February 2022

FOCUS: Strive expansion and protection for Ouaisné supported in Island Plan

Monday 14 February 2022

The Government is supporting the expansion of Strive Health Club in St. Peter into nearby fields as well giving greater planning protection to land around Ouaisné.

With a month to go until States Members debate the mammoth 'Bridging' Island Plan – which will define what can be built and where over the next three years – Environment Minister John Young had lodged amendments following a review of his initial draft by independent inspectors.

Deputy Young has also responded to other amendments proposed by States Members.

So far, there are 97 amendments from backbenchers and Ministers - with more expected to be lodged today.

This is the most that have ever been lodged for a single proposition in Jersey.

The previous record, at 58, was held by the current 2011 Island Plan, and that covered a 10-year period rather than three. 


In the latest batch submitted, Deputy Young says that the development of land to the south of Strive, which is close to the Rugby Club and Airport "may be supported... but only where the public benefit and contribution to the viability and success of local sports can be proven to outweigh any loss or harm to the landscape and agricultural land.”

He adds this could be the provision of netball courts.

Strive fields Island Plan.png

Click to enlarge: The area in yellow includes Strive Health Club and the fields to the south which could become sports facilities.

On the issue of sport, the Minister has also added the FB Fields to the plan’s list of “sports and leisure enhancement areas”, joining Les Quennevais sports centre, Le Rocquier School, Springfield Stadium, the Jersey Rugby Club and leisure areas proposed for the Waterfront.

If this part of the plan is approved, Planning will only support the development of “new or extended large-scale sports, leisure and cultural and cultural facilities” within town, Les Quennevais and these designated areas.

Sand quarrying in St. Ouen’s Bay

In another recently lodged amendment, Deputy Young has also formally set out the details of his U-turn on allowing continued sand extraction in St. Ouen’s Bay.

Initially being against further quarrying, the Minister has changed his mind after the inspectors’ recommended that a triangle of land, which could extend the quarry by another 10 years, is allowed to be excavated. 

Simon Sand and Gravel quarry.jpeg

Pictured: If approved, the sand quarry in St Ouen's Bay will have to be filled in with "inert material from natural sources, as far as possible and practicable".

He said: “Commencement of further extraction would be conditional on the agreement and commencement of a phased restoration plan for the whole quarry site, to be secured through a planning obligation agreement. 

“Planning conditions attached to the original consent for the extraction of sand here require the land to be restored, but the extension of quarrying activity would require and enable a revised restoration plan to be developed for the whole of the site, the phasing and implementation of which would be managed by a legally binding planning obligation agreement, without which consent would not be forthcoming.

“To ensure that the restored site sits appropriately within the context of landscape character of St Ouen’s Bay, it is likely that material will need to be brought onto the site. 

“This should, however, be undertaken using clean, inert material from natural sources as far as possible and practicable, and managed through the appropriate regulatory process.”

Ouaisné and St. Brelade’s Bay

The Minister has agreed with the Constable of St. Brelade to extend the ‘green backdrop zone’, which currently covers high ground overlooking St. Aubin’s Bay, St. Brelade’s Bay and Gorey, to Ouaisné.

This designation protects existing green spaces while ensuring that development does not adversely impact views from the sea, beach and existing built-up areas.

Within St. Brelade’s Bay, the Minister has also agreed that any redevelopment or replacement of an existing building it will not be supported if it is bigger than what was there before.

Marine National Park

Although not backing the full creation of a 900 km2 Marine National Park, which has been called for by charity the Blue Marine Foundation and proposed in an amendment by Senator Lyndon Farnham, the Minister has committed to creating a ‘marine spatial plan’ by 2025 which will develop a ‘network of marine protected areas’.

Marine National Park.png

Pictured: The Environment Minister is against creating a Marine National Park (within the black broken line), arguing that it is premature.

The fundamental issue is a technical one: the Marine National Park is a planning designation, whereas the protection of areas against over-fishing and bad practices falls under fisheries legislation and also has to comply with international rules and regulations, including the post-Brexit trade deal.

The independent inspectors supported the Minister’s view that creating a Marine National Park would be premature and it was best to develop a ‘spatial plan’ ASAP.

Number of houses

In another amendment, the Minister has formally lodged his intention to increase the housing supply target over the three-year plan by 150 homes from 4,150 to 4,300. 

The demand for houses will also increase from 3,750 to 4,000.

This uplift was recommended by the independent inspectors.

Countryside Housing Building.jpeg

Pictured: The Minister has increased the number of houses supplied over the three years of the plan from 4,150 to 4,300.

Deputy Young said: “An effect of accepting this change is that there is a requirement to ensure that the draft plan increases the level of housing supply, and specifically the allocation of sites to provide affordable homes. 

“The draft plan currently makes provision for about 450 affordable homes on sites identified for re-zoning, and this will need to be increased by a further 150 to ensure that the plan makes provision for at least 600 affordable homes through re-zoning.”

The Minister hopes that 337 of these will be built on greenfield sites.

Deputy Young has also firmed up his final list for these affordable home sites.

They are: 

  • G392A La Sente des Fonds, Grouville.
  • J525 La Rue des Buttes, St John.
  • H1219 Grande Route de Mont à l’Abbé, St. Helier. 
  • MN410 Rue des Buttes, St Martin.
  • O594 and 0595 La Rue de la Croix, St. Ouen.
  • P632 La Route de St. Manoir, St. Peter.
  • S413, S415, S415A and S470 La Grande Route de St. Martin, St Saviour.
  • S530 Princes Tower Road, St Saviour.
  • H1248 Highview Lane, St. Helier
  • J1109 La Grande Route de St. Jean, St. John
  • MY563 La Rue de la Rosière & La Rue de la Vallée, St. Mary
  • O622 and O623 La Rue de la Croute, St. Ouen
  • O785 La Rue des Cosnets, St. Ouen, and also, 
  • P558 La Verte Rue, St. Peter
  • P559 La Route du Manoir, St. Peter
  • S341 Bel Air Lane, St. Saviour.

Parking outside homes

The Minister has added a new paragraph to the plan’s policy about off-street parking, which reads: “Development involving the loss of front gardens and their boundary features to provide parking with direct access to/from the highway will not be supported where this would harm the character and appearance of the street scene or compromise highway safety.

The transport policies also make more explicit references to disabled and visitor-parking provision in response to backbench amendments.

Further amendments

More amendments are expected today, which is the deadline for tweaks to be made to amendments. One of these is expected to call from the removal of Field H1248, which is at the back of the former CTV studios at La Pouquelaye from the affordable housing list.

H1248 Highview Lane, St. Helier.jpg

Pictured: An amendment is expected to remove field H1248 at La Pouquelaye from the list of affordable housing sites.

The Minister’s deadline to submit amendments is in a fortnight, with the debate - with two weeks set aside to complete it - due to start on 14 March.

The Minister has accepted a number of amendments submitted by fellow Members so it is expected that debates on those will be swift.


New housing sites added to 'Plan A' list as dairy fields saved

OPINION: Why the Bridging Island Plan bulldozes through our ecology

Key bat roosts at risk under 'fields for homes' plan

FOCUS: Battle lines drawn over affordable homes sites

Campaigners fight building on remaining organic farms

Residents pledge to fight St. Peter's Valley quarry expansion

Discussions before £1.65m field sale to be made public

Artist draws on talents to fight quarry expansion

St. Ouen's Bay quarry "shocked" over plan to shut it by 2024

Bid to cut quarry expansion from Island Plan

INSIGHT: Island Plan...what the people REALLY care about

FOCUS: "We have a housing crisis and a balance has to be struck"

FOCUS: The 'Plan B' housing sites dropped into the Island Plan

"Enough is enough!" Parish pushes back on 'Plan B' sprawl

WATCH: Starting today - meetings that will shape Jersey's future

Housing plan “threatens very existence of dairy industry”

FOCUS: More new fields assessed for affordable housing

Sign up to newsletter



Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.

Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

There are no comments for this article.

To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?